RPTR OBJECTS TO FLYING AS FO TO LESS COMPETENT OLDER; MORE INFIRM PLTS.

Date: 1991-08 · Aircraft: Light Transport; Low Wing; 2 Turboprop Eng

Anomalies: deviation-altitude-excursion-from-assigned-altitude|deviation-track-heading-all-types|deviation-discrepancy-procedural-clearance|deviation-discrepancy-procedural-published-material-policy

Synopsis

RPTR OBJECTS TO FLYING AS FO TO LESS COMPETENT OLDER; MORE INFIRM PLTS.

Narrative

DUE TO INADEQUATE AIRLINE STAFFING; I AM THE ONLY RESERVE PLT (CAPT OR FO) AVAILABLE IN MY BASE. I HAVE REPEATEDLY BEEN ASSIGNED TO FLY AS A FO; I HAVE FOUND AMBIGUOUS DEFINITION OF DUTIES IN SOME INSTANCES DUE TO VAGUE/CONTRADICTORY MANUAL AND CONTRACT LANGUAGE AND DUE TO TOTAL LACK OF CRM TRAINING; ALL OF WHICH PROMOTE A WIDE VARIETY OF PREFERENCES AND TECHNIQUES. ADDITIONALLY; I AM NOT USED TO; NOR DO I ENJOY; ACTING AS A SECOND IN COMMAND TO SOME OF MY COLLEAGUES. IN THESE UNCOMFORTABLE CIRCUMSTANCES; INFO 'SHARING' CAN BE DIFFICULT. IN THIS INSTANCE; THE PIC (PF) MISREAD THE DME DATA DISPLAYED ON HIS EHSI; WHICH CAUSED HIM TO BREAK OUT ON THE ILS TOO HIGH; TOO FAST; TO LAND ON THE ILS RWY (34R). I HAD QUERIED HIM; AS HAD THE TWR; AS TO WHETHER HE COULD COMPLETE A LNDG. I DID NOT REALIZE HE WAS DISORIENTED. FELT HE WAS OBSTINATELY PRESSING ON. AS IMMEDIATE SAFETY WAS NOT IN QUESTION; I TOOK NO ACTION. ON REACHING VFR CONDITIONS; THE CAPT REALIZED HIS ERROR; WAS QUITE STARTLED. WE EXECUTED A VFR GAR TO A VFR LNDG; IN THE COURSE OF WHICH THE CAPT EXCEEDED THE ALT ISSUED BY THE TWR (TO MAINTAIN AT OR BELOW 1500 MSL); AS WELL AS THE 200 KIAS ATA SPD LIMIT. I POINTED OUT THESE DEVS; HE MADE NO OBVIOUS EFFORT TO CORRECT THEM. THE TWR MADE NO COMMENT. I HAVE FOUND THIS CAPT TO HAVE POOR EYESIGHT; TO BE VERY HARD OF HEARING.

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.