Captain reported local control position in tower issuing route clearances along with control instructions resulted in frequency overload and distraction while executing a precision approach in poor weather conditions. Controller stated this is facility's normal procedure.
Synopsis
Captain reported local control position in tower issuing route clearances along with control instructions resulted in frequency overload and distraction while executing a precision approach in poor weather conditions. Controller stated this is facility's normal procedure.
Narrative
Safety concern while conducting ILS during at-mins IMC conditions at PHX. While cleared for ILS Runway 26; the Tower frequency was clogged up due to the Tower Controller's excessive transmissions. He was transmitting full re-route clearances to aircraft on Tower frequency. Normally this might not be an issue if the airport wasn't so busy; arrival rates were low and it was VMC. However; this night the weather was at mins; thunderstorms in the area and the probability of a go-around was high. To simultaneous broadcast on both Clearance Delivery and Tower frequencies is completely unsafe. It's very distracting to have a full re-route clearance broadcasted on Tower frequencies; while aircraft are conducting high workload; low visibility/low ceiling instrument approaches. If this is normal practice; which the Controller said; it was when queried on the taxi post landing. I find this to be unacceptable; especially with all the recent close calls seen on national news. Stop the simultaneous broadcasting on tower frequency during busy times. If the excuse is the lack of ATC manning; fix it. And here's an idea. If there is a last minute re-route that needs to be communicated; send it via CPDLC or utilize clearance delivery's reserved frequency.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.