FLC OF MLG CLRED TO 3000 ON A LOC GS ILS 205 DEG AT SPOKANE HAD GPWS. FO FLYING CLBED TO INTERCEPT GS AND PROCEEDED WITH APCH AND LNDG.
Synopsis
FLC OF MLG CLRED TO 3000 ON A LOC GS ILS 205 DEG AT SPOKANE HAD GPWS. FO FLYING CLBED TO INTERCEPT GS AND PROCEEDED WITH APCH AND LNDG.
Narrative
WE WERE CLRED FOR APCH TO SPOKANE INTL ARPT ILS RWY 21. AT TIME WE WERE ON VECTORS; APPROXIMATE HDG OF 260 DEGS INBOUND FROM SE. OUR FLT WAS FROM CHICAGO. INITIALLY ABOUT 25 MI OUT; CLRED TO 8000 FT. I WAS FLYING AND HAD BRIEFED MSA ALTS. IT WAS NOTED THAT 8000 FT PUT US 900 FT ABOVE MSA. I BRIEFED A CAT I AND CAT II APCH AS WX WAS 5 BROKEN 1 1/2 S.F. BRIEFED THAT WITH TERRAIN IF WE GOT GPWS WE WERE OUT OF THERE FOR GAR. AS FLT PROGRESSED APCH CTL AT SPOKANE KEPT GIVING US LOWER AND LOWER ALTS. 15 MI OUT WE WERE GIVEN 5000 FT THEN 4000 FT. ON APCH PAGE OR PLATE FOR ILS RWY 21; ALT FOR THE ILS OUTSIDE OF PHORT OM IS 4300 FT; HOWEVER; IF IT IS A LOC APCH DSCNT TO 3600 IS ALLOWED. FROM HDG AND VECTOR WE WERE BEING GIVEN WE SAW THAT WE WOULD BE ALMOST AT PHORT OM BEFORE LOC CAPTURE. JUST OUTSIDE OF PHORT WE WERE 'CLRED TO 3000 UNTIL ESTABLISHED ON LOC; CLRED ILS 21 APCH AT SPOKANE.' I SAW WE WERE BELOW GS BUT THOUGHT SINCE THE INTERCEPT WAS SO CLOSE TO PHORT THAT APCH WAS TRYING TO KEEP US COMING DOWN. ONCE ESTABLISHED ON LOC; APCH GAVE US A SAFETY ADVISORY THAT WE WERE BELOW SAFE VECTORING ALT FOR THAT PART OF APCH; AND THAT WE SHOULD BE AT 3700 FT. MY ALT WAS 3300 FT. I IMMEDIATELY ADDED PWR; AND BELOW GS LIGHT CAME ON SIMULTANEOUSLY. I REINTERCEPTED GS AND LANDED WITHOUT ANY PROBLEM. BOTH CAPT AND I HEARD AND RESPONDED TO 'CLRED TO 3000 UNTIL ESTABLISHED; CLRED ILS 21 APCH.' WE TRUSTED APCH TO BE PROVIDING US WITH TERRAIN PROTECTION; BUT THEY WERE NOT. IF I WOULD HAVE JUST FOLLOWED GS DOWN I WOULD HAVE BEEN ALL RIGHT; JUST DO THE APCH AS ON PLATE IT WOULD BE FINE BUT SPOKANE APCH BEARS A RESPONSIBILITY FOR SETTING A CREW UP FOR THIS. THEY CLRED US TO 3000 FT. WE SHOULD HAVE QUESTIONED IT SINCE ARPT ELEVATION IS 2370 FT BUT THEY CONSISTENTLY DO THIS IN BOTH VISUAL AND IMC CONDITIONS. IN FUTURE I WILL NOT BE LED DOWN THE DARK PATH BY ATC WITHOUT KNOWING WHY. ALSO; IT IS OF UTMOST IMPORTANCE TO KNOW TERRAIN; BE VIGILANT; NOT BECOME COMPLACENT ABOUT ATC PROVIDING TERRAIN CLRNC FOR YOU. THERE ARE TRAPS I FOUND OUT; THAT WHILE LEGAL; IT MAY NOT BE SAFE. SPOKANE IS A PROBLEM; BOTH WITH TERRAIN; BUT ALSO OF POOR HANDLING OF LARGE TURBO JET ACFT. THEY TRY TO CTL US LIKE SMALLER ACFT; BUT IT JUST DOESN'T WORK. CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: RPTR HAD LITTLE TO ADD TO HIS RPT. HE IS NOT CERTAIN IN HIS MIND THAT THE CTLR GAVE THEM A BAD ALT. NOT A NORMAL PROC. UNKNOWN WHY CTLR WOULD GIVE SO LOW AN ALT THAT DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE LEGAL.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.