ATX PIC MAKES APCH TO ARPT WHEN WX MINS LESS THAN REQUIRED FOR APCH.
Synopsis
ATX PIC MAKES APCH TO ARPT WHEN WX MINS LESS THAN REQUIRED FOR APCH.
Narrative
ON FEB/92 I WAS FLYING FROM CID TO DSM. PRIOR TO TKOF I HAD OBTAINED A WX BRIEFING FOR THE RTE OF FLT AND CURRENT WX AT DES MOINES WAS 200 FT OVCST 1 MI DRIZZLE AND FOG. WE DEPARTED FROM CEDAR RAPIDS TO DES MOINES. PRIOR TO CONTACTING DES MOINES APCH WE CONTACTED THE DES MOINES TWR FOR CURRENT WX AT THE ARPT. WE HAD MINS FOR LNDG ON 30R. WHEN WE CONTACTED DES MOINES APCH; HE HAD ADVISED US THAT THE RVR WAS 3000 FOR RWY 12L; EXPECT ILS 12L AND GAVE US RADAR VECTORS FOR THE APCH. SINCE THE RVR OF 3000 IS BELOW MINS FOR RWY 12L (MIN RVR 4000) WE REQUESTED THE RVR FOR RWY 30R. THE RVR FOR THIS RWY WAS 2600 RVR WHICH WAS ABOVE MIN OF 2400 RVR. WE REQUESTED 30R. APCH THEN GAVE US A VECTOR DIRECT TO DES MOINES VOR. WE WERE ALSO INFORMED THAT THE GS WAS OUT OF SVC ON 30R. AT THIS TIME WE STILL HAD MINS FOR RWY 30R. DES MOINES APCH ADVISE THAT THE ACTIVE RWY WAS 12L AND RVR 3000 AND GAVE US A VECTOR TOWARD 12L. ONCE BEING VECTORED FOR AN APCH TO DES MOINES ARPT 12L; ONCE AGAIN WE ASKED FOR THE WX FOR 30R. WE STILL HAD LNDG MINS FOR 30R. APCH CONTINUED TO VECTOR US FOR THE APCH FOR 12L AND CLRED US FOR AN APCH; KNOWING THE WX WAS BELOW LNDG MINS FOR 12L; AND KNOWING WE WANTED 30R. ONCE INSIDE THE MARKER THE TWR CLRED US TO LAND. ON THE APCH 12L WE BROKE OUT OF THE OVCST BEFORE ARRIVING AT THE MIDDLE MARKER WITH THE RWY IN SIGHT. WE HAD EASILY 3/4 TO 1 MI VISIBILITY. ONCE CLRING THE RWY I ADVISED THE TWR OF THE VISIBILITY. WE BELIEVE THE CONTRIBUTING FACTOR TO THIS CONFLICT WAS THAT APCH AND TWR WAS USING 12L FOR DEPS AND LETTING US LAND 30R WOULD INTERFERED WITH DEPS. OFF 12L; TWR AND APCH MADE THE DECISION WHERE TO LAND; AND NOT COMPLYING TO OUR WISHES.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.