A NON STAGE III ACR LGT ACFT LANDED WITH CLRNC AFTER THE LCL CURFEW. THE AIRCREW TRIED TO REMIND THE CTLR THAT THEY WERE NOT LEGAL TO LAND; BUT CLRNC WAS GIVEN ANYWAY.

Date: 1992-05 · Aircraft: Large Transport; Low Wing; 3 Turbojet Eng

Anomalies: deviation-discrepancy-procedural-far|other-unspecified

Synopsis

A NON STAGE III ACR LGT ACFT LANDED WITH CLRNC AFTER THE LCL CURFEW. THE AIRCREW TRIED TO REMIND THE CTLR THAT THEY WERE NOT LEGAL TO LAND; BUT CLRNC WAS GIVEN ANYWAY.

Narrative

DUE TO TSTMS IN DCA AREA; FLTS WERE DELAYED. OUR TRIP TO DCA WOULD NOT DEPART LGA UNTIL AFTER AA00 LCL TIME. WE REALIZED THAT OUR DEP TIME; AND ANTICIPATED RWY DELAYS AT LGA; WOULD PRECLUDE OUR FLYING TO DCA; AND THAT ARRANGEMENTS WOULD HAVE TO BE MADE FOR HANDLING AT IAD (DULLES). THIS WAS DUE TO OUR EXPECTED ARR IN THE WASHINGTON AREA AFTER THE CURFEW AT DCA. (OUR LGT WAS NOT STAGE III). ENRTE PORTION OF FLT WAS UNEVENTFUL; UNTIL WE CONTACTED DCA APCH ON 124.2 OVER BWI. HE TOLD US TO EXPECT A MT VERNON VISUAL TO RWY 36. THE CAPT (PNF) ADVISED THAT WE WERE 'NEGATIVE STAGE III.' CTLR SAID 'ROGER; EXPECT MT VERNON VISUAL TO 36.' THE FO AND I BOTH EXPRESSED RESERVATION ABOUT LNDG AT DCA; DESPITE THE CTLRS ACTIONS. HOWEVER; THE CAPT DECIDED TO LAND; AND WE EXECUTED A MT VERNON VISUAL; AND A NORMAL LNDG. AS WE TAXIED TO THE GATE WE NOTICED OTHER ACFT LNDG; HOWEVER; I DO NOT RECALL WHAT TYPES OF ACFT THESE WERE. WE RECEIVED APCH CLRNC AT APPROX BB00 LCL AND LANDED APPROX BB05. WE ADVISED APCH OF OUR NEGATIVE STAGE III; AND WERE ACKNOWLEDGED. THEN CLRED FOR APCH AND LNDG. IT IS UNCERTAIN WHETHER ANY ACTION IS BEING PURSUED OR NOT. I DO FEEL; HOWEVER; THAT EVERYONE SHOULD BE AWARE OF CURFEWS. IF THE CTLR CLRED YOU AFTER YOU ADVISE HIM OF YOUR STATUS; IT WOULD SEEM HE HAS TAKEN RESPONSIBILITY FOR RELAXING CURFEW RULES. HAD I BEEN THE CAPT; I WOULD HAVE REFUSED THE CLRNC AND PROCEEDED TO DULLES (WHICH WE HAD NOT BEEN FILED FOR OR CLRED TO); HOWEVER; I FEEL THAT THE CAPT SATISFIED HIS OBLIGATION TO ADVISE ATC IF A CLRNC RECEIVED WOULD BE CONTRARY TO RULE. I FEEL THAT ATC SHOULD NOT HAVE CLRED US TO DCA ONCE THEY KNEW OF OUR STATUS; IF CURFEW RULES WERE IN EFFECT AND BEING ENFORCED.

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.