ALTDEV ALT UNDERSHOT ALT XING RESTRICTION NOT MET IN AN OPPOSITE DIRECTION TFC SITUATION.
Synopsis
ALTDEV ALT UNDERSHOT ALT XING RESTRICTION NOT MET IN AN OPPOSITE DIRECTION TFC SITUATION.
Narrative
CLBING THROUGH FL260; ZJX ASKED IF WE COULD CROSS 20 DME S OF CRAIG VOR AT FL330. WE WERE CURRENTLY AT 48 DME S WITH A RATE OF CLB OF 2000 FPM PLUS. OUR WT WAS 154000 POUNDS AND OUR GND SPD WAS 360 KTS. OUR IAS WAS 300 KTS. COMPUTING THIS INFO; THE FO AND I CONCURRED THAT WE SHOULD BE ABLE TO REACH FL330 WITHIN THE 28 MI TO GO. AS A BACKUP; I COULD TRADEOFF SOME AIRSPD FOR AN INCREASED RATE OF CLB. THE FO REPLIED TO CTR; 'I THINK WE CAN.' CTR THEN CLRED US TO CROSS THE 20 DME S OF CRAIG AT FL330. I MAINTAINED A 2000 FPM RATE OF CLB UNTIL OUT OF FL300 AT WHICH TIME I NOTICED THAT THE OUTSIDE AIR TEMP WAS INCREASING AND OUR RATE OF CLB STARTED TO DECREASE. I THEN BEGAN TRADING AIRSPD FOR AN INCREASED RATE OF CLB. I ALSO INCREASED THRUST TO 'MAX ALLOWABLE FOR A 2 MIN PERIOD' (ACFT ENG LIMITATION). HOWEVER; THE OUTSIDE AIR TEMP KEPT INCREASING AND WE WERE ONLY ABLE TO MAINTAIN A 1000 FPM RATE OF CLB OUT OF FL320 AT 23.5 DME. APCHING 20 DME; WE WERE LEAVING FL32.5 AND WERE LEVELING OFF AT APPROX 19 DME. DURING THE LAST 1000 FT; THE ACFT STARTED DRIFTING TO THE L OF CTRLINE. I ELECTED TO MAKE NO TURN TO CORRECT IN ORDER TO ACHIEVE MAX CLB PERFORMANCE; AND THAT WE WERE STILL IN PROTECTED AIRSPACE. (INSIDE THE 4 MI EACH SIDE OF CTRLINE AIRSPACE). ABOUT 10 SECONDS AFTER LEVEL AT FL330 (AND REGAINING AIRSPD); CTR POINTED OUT TFC AT 11 O'CLOCK AND 8 MI AT FL310. OUR TCASII SHOWED NO TFC NOR GAVE ANY AURAL ALERTS. WE SIGHTED THE TFC (AT FL310) AND IT APPEARED TO BE MORE THAN 5 MI (OPPOSITE DIRECTION). 2 SECTORS LATER; AND PRIOR TO BEING TURNED OVER TO ZDC; ZJX ASKED US TO CALL QUALITY ASSURANCE AT ZJX OVER A POSSIBLE INCIDENT S OF CRAIG. OUR FLT PLAN SHOWED A NORMAL TEMP LAPSE RATE AT OUR ALTS AND POS. HAD THE INVERSION NOT BEEN THIS EXTENSIVE; WE WOULD HAVE BEEN LEVEL AT 330 PRIOR TO THE 20 DME. IN ACCEPTING THIS XING RESTRICTION; I WAS ASSUMING NORMAL FLT CONDITIONS. I WILL NO LONGER ACCEPT A CLRNC THAT REQUIRES OPTIMUM OPERATING PARAMETERS SUCH AS A CLB RESTRICTION. I DO BELIEVE THAT CTR SHOULD ASSIGN EVASIVE HDGS WHEN A POSSIBILITY OF A CONFLICT ALERT EXISTS (NONE WAS ASSIGNED); OR IMMEDIATELY ASSIGNED A LOWER ALT (IF STILL BELOW THE XING TFC ALT). COM WERE ALSO SOMEWHAT AT FAULT. 'I THINK WE CAN' WAS NOT A DEFINITE YES AND ALSO THE XING TFC'S POS WAS NOT STATED UNTIL WE WERE LEVEL AT FL330. THERE IS OBVIOUSLY A LOT LEFT TO BE LEARNED IN AVIATION SAFETY. YOUR DATA BANKS ARE A BIG STEP IN THIS DIRECTION. SUPPLEMENTAL INFO FROM ACN 210906: AT FL325; ATC REPLIED 'SAY YOUR DME.' I RESPONDED 'JUST ABOUT 20 S;' AS THE DME COUNTER WAS READING 21 DME. ATC THEN REPLIED 'SAY YOUR ALT.' I RESPONDED 'FL325.' ATC THEN REQUESTED WE CALL THEM REACHING FL330. AT FL327 I REPLIED 'LEVELING AT FL330.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.