AN SMA PLT HAD TO CLB INTO THE CLOUDS WITHOUT IFR CLRNC BECAUSE HE WAS UNABLE TO CONTACT ANYONE WHILE VFR UNDERNEATH.

Date: 1992-07 · Aircraft: Small Aircraft; High Wing; 1 Eng; Fixed Gear

Anomalies: deviation-discrepancy-procedural-far|inflight-event-encounter-vfr-in-imc|inflight-event-encounter-weather-turbulence

Synopsis

AN SMA PLT HAD TO CLB INTO THE CLOUDS WITHOUT IFR CLRNC BECAUSE HE WAS UNABLE TO CONTACT ANYONE WHILE VFR UNDERNEATH.

Narrative

AN IFR FLT PLAN WAS FILED FOR A FLT FROM FDK TO 2G4. MORGANTOWN FSS WAS RPTING 4500 BROKEN AND WX/STORMS WAS EXPECTED LATER THAT DAY. FDK WAS 3500 TO 3000. I DEPARTED FDK VFR AND PLANNED TO PICK UP MY CLRNC OVER MARTINSBURG WITH DULLES APCH (WHICH I HAVE DONE BEFORE). JUST BEFORE I CALLED DULLES; ANOTHER ACFT CALLED FOR A CLRNC INTO MARTINSBURG FROM HAGERSTOWN. DULLES RESPONDED 'CAN YOU CLB VFR TO 4000?' THE RESPONSE WAS 'NEGATIVE.' DULLES RESPONDED 'REMAIN VFR.' I CALLED DULLES APCH TO PICK UP MY CLRNC; WAS ASSIGNED A SQUAWK CODE AND WAS TOLD TO STANDBY WHILE HE TRIED TO ACTIVATE MY CLRNC. MEANWHILE; I PROCEEDED ON MY FILED RTE VFR. APPROX 15 MI W OF MARTINSBURG; DULLES SAID THAT I WAS LEAVING HIS AIRSPACE; TOLD ME TO SQUAWK 1200 AND GAVE ME ZDC'S FREQ. AT THIS POINT; ASSUMING I COULDN'T CLB TO THE MVA/MEA TO PICK UP MY CLRNC; I CONTINUED VFR. FOR THE NEXT 25 TO 30 MI THE WX LOOKED OKAY UNTIL I REACHED KEYSER; WV. WHERE I MADE A 180 DUE TO VISIBILITY; BUT EVERYTHING CLOSED IN BEHIND ME. I CALLED CTR BUT THEY COULD NOT HEAR ME BECAUSE OF MY LOW ALT; I HEARD OTHER ACFT TALKING TO CTR SO I DECLARED AN EMER FOR AN IMMEDIATE IFR CLRNC WHICH ANOTHER ACFT RELAYED TO CTR. JUST AS I WAS REACHING CTLED AIRSPACE AT 3000 FT; I ESTABLISHED RADIO AND RADAR CONTACT WITH CTR AND HE GAVE ME A CLRNC. THE FLT CONTINUED WITH NO OTHER PROBLEMS. CONCLUSION: BECAUSE FDK ARPT FALLS UNDER BALTIMORE'S AIRSPACE; I SHOULD HAVE FILED FROM MARTINSBURG TO PICK UP MY CLRNC WITH DULLES. CONCERNING CONTINUED VFR FLT INTO MARGINAL CONDITIONS; I THINK SEVERAL FACTORS PLAYED A PART IN MY DECISION. FIRST; BECAUSE I HEARD A REQUEST FOR AN IFR CLRNC DENIED BECAUSE THE PLT COULD NOT CLB VFR TO MVA/MEA; I WAS RELUCTANT TO CALL CTR. SECOND; MORGANTOWN FSS HAD RPTED 4500 BROKEN BEFORE MY DEP; I THOUGHT CONDITIONS WOULD NOT BECOME ANY WORSE AND I WAS FAMILIAR WITH THE TERRAIN. I WILL DEFINITELY USE A MORE CONSERVATIVE DECISION PROCESS CONCERNING VFR FLT.

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.