SMA X HAD LTSS FROM SMT Y ON VISUAL APCH. SYS ERROR.
Synopsis
SMA X HAD LTSS FROM SMT Y ON VISUAL APCH. SYS ERROR.
Narrative
I WAS WORKING THE FLT DATA POS IN THE PANAMA CITY; FL; ATCT (PFN) WHEN I OBSERVED THE FOLLOWING OCCURRENCE. SMA X WAS GIVEN AN IFR RELEASE BY TYNDALL AIR FORCE BASE RAPCON; THE IFR CTLING FACILITY FOR PFN; OFF RWY 14 AT PFN. SMA X'S INSTRUCTIONS WERE TO TURN L ON COURSE AND CLB AND MAINTAIN 5000 FT. SMT Y WAS; AT THIS TIME; 10 MI N OF PFN; INBOUND IFR ON A VISUAL APCH TO RWY 23. THE DEP INSTRUCTIONS FOR SMA X TOOK HIM DIRECTLY INTO A HEAD-ON SIT WITH SMT Y; ALTHOUGH THEY WERE APPROX 7 MI APART AT THIS TIME. AS SMA X WAS CLBING; SMT Y WAS DSNDING. THEY WERE APPROX 5 MI APART AT THE SAME ALT. WHEN SMA X PASSED OVER SMT Y THERE WAS ONLY 500 FT OF VERT SEPARATION BTWN THE 2 ACFT. THE LCL CTLR SAID AT THAT POINT THEY WERE BOTH IN SIGHT AND COULD BE SEPARATED VISUALLY. SMT Y WAS ISSUED TFC CALLS AT LEAST TWICE ON SMA X AND WAS TOLD TO DEVIATE TO AVOID THE OTHER ACFT. WHEN THE ACFT WERE APPROX 1 MI APART; SMT Y SAW SMA X AND STAYED ON COURSE; THUS PASSING BELOW HIM. THE WATCH SUPVR AT TYNDALL AIR FORCE BASE RAPCON WAS NOTIFIED OF THE INCIDENT AND ADMITTED THE DEP APCH CTLR MADE A MISTAKE AND THAT TRAINING WAS GOING ON AT THE TIME. THE EXCUSE OF 'TRAINING' IS USED OFTEN AT TYNDALL RAPCON TO JUSTIFY LOSS OF SEPARATION OR VIOLATIONS OF THE PFN ATCT/TYNDALL RAPCON LOA. CLOSER SUPERVISION OF DEVELOPMENTAL CTLRS MAY ELIMINATE THESE AND OTHER MISTAKES.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.