RPTR CITES ACFT EQUIP DESIGN PROB AS CAUSE FOR ACFT DAMAGE WHEN NOSE GEAR COLLAPSED ON RWY.
Synopsis
RPTR CITES ACFT EQUIP DESIGN PROB AS CAUSE FOR ACFT DAMAGE WHEN NOSE GEAR COLLAPSED ON RWY.
Narrative
WHILE CONDUCTING FLT TEST PROGRAM IN MY NEWLY BUILT GLASAIR I-FT AND LNDG AT HERMISTON; THE NOSE GEAR FAILED AND THE NOSE OF THE AIRPLANE DROPPED TO THE RWY RESULTING IN A PROP STRIKE; SEPARATION OF THE NOSE GEAR FROM THE ACFT AND OTHER DAMAGE. PRIOR TO LNDG AT HERMISTON I HAD LANDED AT ANOTHER NEARBY PAVED ARPT AND ON ROLLOUT HAD HEARD A PAIR OF SNAPPING NOISES AND WHAT FELT LIKE WHEEL SHIMMY. HOWEVER; THE AIRPLANE TAXIED OKAY SO I RETURNED TO THE END OF THE RWY AND TOOK OFF. APPARENTLY; THE RUBBER BISCUIT ASSEMBLY HAD SEPARATED; ALLOWING THE NOSE GEAR TO DROP INTO A NEAR VERT POS. THE LNDG AT HERMISTON WAS A NORMAL SHORT-FIELD LNDG APCH AT 70-75 MPH (VSO IS 56 OR 57 MPH); WHICH IS MORE THAN 1.2 VSO. THE MAIN LNDG GEAR CONTACTED THE RWY JUST PAST THE NUMBERS. (WINDS WERE LIGHT AND VARIABLE). THE ACFT BALLOONED BACK INTO THE AIR 2 TO 3 FT AND CAME BACK DOWN ON THE MAIN GEAR WITH A VERY NOSE-HIGH ATTITUDE. THE NOSE BEGAN TO FALL WHEN I HEARD A LOUD BANG WHICH WAS THE NOSE GEAR CONTACTING THE RWY AND BREAKING OFF. OBVIOUSLY THE NOSE CONTINUED TO DROP TO THE PAVEMENT; RESULTING IN THE AFOREMENTIONED PROP STRIKE AND OTHER DAMAGE. EXAMINATION OF THE FAILED PARTS SHOWED: FAULTY DESIGN -- NO THROUGH BOLT. FAULTY EXECUTION OF THE DESIGN -- TACK-WELDS WHICH WERE 'COLD WELDS' (4 EACH) AND WHICH HAD BEEN GND OFF ALMOST COMPLETELY. THE PARTS HAD BEEN FURNISHED AS PART OF THE GLASAIR I-FT KIT. THE LNDG; IN MY OPINION; WAS NOT A PARTICULARLY HARD LNDG AND THERE WAS NO DAMAGE TO THE MAIN LNDG GEAR.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.