FLC OF AN ACR WDB SIGHTED ANOTHER WDB CONVERGING AT THE SAME HIGH CRUISE ALT AND WAS SUBSEQUENTLY GIVEN A HIGHER ALT. AT APPROX THE SAME TIME; THE ACFT TCASII GAVE AN RA TO DSND WHICH WAS NOT RESPONDED TO SINCE THE OTHER ACFT WAS IN SIGHT.
Synopsis
FLC OF AN ACR WDB SIGHTED ANOTHER WDB CONVERGING AT THE SAME HIGH CRUISE ALT AND WAS SUBSEQUENTLY GIVEN A HIGHER ALT. AT APPROX THE SAME TIME; THE ACFT TCASII GAVE AN RA TO DSND WHICH WAS NOT RESPONDED TO SINCE THE OTHER ACFT WAS IN SIGHT.
Narrative
I SAW ACFT AT MY 12:30 TO 1:00 O'CLOCK POS. I VERIFIED ITS ALT AS BEING (TCASII) FL370; THE SAME AS MY OWN. I CALLED WINNIPEG CTR AND SAID 'ARE YOU AWARE THAT I HAVE AN ACFT AT MY 12:30 POS FL370 AND CONVERGING?' REPLY FROM WINNIPEG 'CLB TO 390!' THE FO SET THE NEW ALT AND I HIT THE FLT LEVEL CHANGE BUTTON FOR EXPEDITED CLB. WE THEN GOT THE TA AND ONCE ESTABLISHED IN THE CLB WE RECEIVED RA TO DSND. SINCE I HAD THE ACFT IN SIGHT THE ENTIRE TIME I DID NOT THINK IT WOULD BE WISE TO DECREASE SEPARATION BY FOLLOWING THE TCASII RA COMMAND. TO KEEP THINGS SIMPLE; WE WERE ABOVE THE INTRUDER ACFT AT 37500 FT AND CLBING WHEN WE RECEIVED THE RA TO DSND -- NO WAY! I FOLLOWED THE ATC CLRNC AND CLBED TO FL390 THE RA STOPPED -- AND THE CTLR DIDN'T SAY A WORD. IT WAS VERY QUIET ON THE FREQ. IT IS MY BELIEF THAT IF IT WERE NOT VFR TODAY AND I DID NOT SEE THAT OTHER ACFT 2 747'S WOULD HAVE COLLIDED TODAY AND IN ADDITION TCASII FAILED BY GIVING ME A DSND COMMAND INSTEAD OF TELLING ME TO CLB. I BELIEVE THIS WAS AN ATC CTLR FAILURE AS BOTH ACFT WERE IN RADAR CONTACT.
More incidents for this aircraft family →
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.