SMA ON TRAINING FLT HAS NMAC WITH LEAR JET WHEN ON FINAL APCH. CTLR TURNS RPTR ACFT INTO ONCOMING TFC.
Synopsis
SMA ON TRAINING FLT HAS NMAC WITH LEAR JET WHEN ON FINAL APCH. CTLR TURNS RPTR ACFT INTO ONCOMING TFC.
Narrative
AT APPROX 6 MI OUT; APCH CTL CLRED ME FOR VISUAL APCH TO RWY 1L. MY HDG WAS 010 DEGS AND I WAS ON A STRAIGHT IN APCH. I WAS TOLD TO MAINTAIN 2000 FT AND NAS ON VECTORS. I WAS CONCERNED THAT IT WOULD BE DIFFICULT TO SLOW DOWN THE ACFT AND DSND TO REACH THE RWY. AT APPROX 3 MI OUT AND STILL ON APCH FREQ; I WAS INFORMED OF A LEAR WHO WOULD BE LNDG PRIOR; AND RECEIVED A COMMAND TO TURN TO 090 DEGS AND MAINTAIN 2000 FT. I SAW THE LEAR ENTERING FROM MY R. THE LEAR WAS RATHER CLOSE. I ATTEMPTED TO ASSESS THE SIT AND WAS GIVEN THE COMMAND AGAIN. I THOUGHT IT RATHER ODD THAT THE CTLR WOULD BE TURNING ME TOWARD THE TFC; TURNING ME OFF THE EXTENDED CTRLINE WHEN I WAS CLRED FOR THE APCH; AND THAT I HADN'T BEEN TURNED OVER TO TWR AT THIS POINT. IN THE CONFUSION; I HAD INADVERTENTLY DSNDED BTWN 200 AND 400 FT; BUT I MADE THE TURN AS REQUESTED BY ATC. THE LEAR HAD BEEN TOLD TO 'KEEP IT TIGHT' BUT HADN'T; AND PASSED UNDER MY NOSE; BARELY MISSING ME. BY THIS TIME I WAS APPROX 2 1/2 MI FROM RWY THRESHOLD AND AT HDG 090 DEGS AND WAS TURNED OVER TO TWR WHO CLRED ME TO LAND WITH 'S TURNS APPROVED.' THIS IS NOT STANDARD PROC IN A TWIN; BUT I COMPLIED; STILL SHAKEN BY THE NEAR MISS. I LANDED WITHOUT FURTHER INCIDENT. ATC SHOULD HAVE EITHER GIVEN THE LEAR A 360 DEG TURN FOR SPACING; SLOWED HIM DOWN SO SPDS WERE COMPATIBLE; OR GIVEN HIM RWY 01R. THEY ALSO COULD HAVE GIVEN ME A 360 DEG; BUT TURNING ME TOWARD OPPOSING TFC WAS COUNTER INTUITIVE TO BASIC SURVIVAL INSTINCTS. GIVING S TURNS TO A TWIN WAS ALSO A POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS SIT IN CASE OF SINGLE ENG FAILURE. I BELIEVE THAT APCH FORGOT ABOUT ME AND WAS ATTEMPTING TO RECTIFY THE ENSUING TFC CONFLICT. IN RETROSPECT; I SHOULD HAVE COMPLIED MORE QUICKLY WITH ATC'S INSTRUCTION; BUT IT DID NOT SEEM SAFE TO DO SO AT THAT TIME. I ALSO SHOULD HAVE MAINTAINED ALT AND REQUESTED A GAR OR A 360 DEG. IT SEEMED THAT THE LEAR WAS GIVEN PRIORITY ALTHOUGH MY APCH SPD WAS PROBABLY ONLY 20 KTS LESS THAN HIS; AND I WAS ALREADY ESTABLISHED ON EXTENDED CTRLINE AND HAD BEEN CLRED FOR A VISUAL APCH. ALSO; CLRING SOMEONE FOR A VISUAL APCH WITH AN ALT RESTR MADE NO SENSE. 'SLAM DUNKING' A TWIN IS NOT RECOMMENDED; ESPECIALLY ON A NIGHT OF VERY LIGHT TFC.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.