PLTDEV OCCURRED WHEN THE MTR CLBED THROUGH THE MAINTAIN ALT ASSIGNED BY THE DEP CTLR FOR TFC SEPARATION FROM AN OVERFLT ACFT.
Synopsis
PLTDEV OCCURRED WHEN THE MTR CLBED THROUGH THE MAINTAIN ALT ASSIGNED BY THE DEP CTLR FOR TFC SEPARATION FROM AN OVERFLT ACFT.
Narrative
I WAS WORKING THE DEP SECTOR FOR PENSACOLA; WHICH WAS DEPARTING RWY 01. THE MIL JET WAS FILED OFF ON A TRADR 4 SID. THE SID HAD AN INITIAL RESTR REGARDING THE ACFT'S CLB RATE TO 3000 FT. IT THEN HAS A RESTR THAT HAS THE ACFT MAKE A CLBING L TURN TO 4000 FT AND HOLD 4000 FT UNTIL A RADIAL S OF NPA. AT THE TIME THE SIT OCCURRED; I HAD AN OVERFLT WHOSE COURSE WOULD TAKE HIM 4 MI N OF PENSACOLA WBOUND. RECOGNIZING A POTENTIAL CONFLICT; I TOLD THE MIL JET ON DEP TO 'MAINTAIN 3000 FT; COMPLY WITH RESTRS.' I INTENDED FOR THE ACFT TO MAINTAIN THE SPECIFIED CLB RATE TO 3000 FT; AND THEN FLY THE DEP COURSE OF THE SID AT 3000 FT UNTIL FURTHER ADVISED. THE PLT UNDERSTOOD THE INSTRUCTION TO MEAN HE SHOULD CLB TO 3000 FT; AND THEN COMPLY WITH THE RESTR TO CLB TO 4000 FT IN HIS TURN. THE ACFT PASSED WITH 1200 FT VERT SEPARATION AND THEN I VECTORED THE MIL JET TO MAINTAIN LATERAL DIVERGENCE. IN HINDSIGHT I REALIZE THAT THE PHRASEOLOGY I USED COULD BE MISLEADING. HOWEVER; I WAS TRAINED TO USE THIS PHRASEOLOGY AND IT USED TO BE IN FAA HANDBOOK 7110.65. IT IS NO LONGER THERE; AND I WAS NOT BRIEFED THAT IT HAD BEEN REMOVED. ALSO; THERE IS NO CLR PHRASEOLOGY OR GUIDANCE ON HOW TO LEGALLY RESTRICT THE ALT OF A SID DEP. THIS LEADS TO CONFUSION WHEN CTLRS ARE USING DIFFERENT WORDS TO MEAN THE SAME THING.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.