AN ACR WDB CAPT REFUSED TO LET HIS SO COMPLETE THE CHKLIST AS PRINTED. ACFT EQUIP PROB HIGH CSD RPM.
Synopsis
AN ACR WDB CAPT REFUSED TO LET HIS SO COMPLETE THE CHKLIST AS PRINTED. ACFT EQUIP PROB HIGH CSD RPM.
Narrative
ACFT WAS TAXIING OUT FOR DEP. THE #2 GENERATOR AND FIELD TRIPPED OFF THE LINE. I PULLED OUT THE CHKLIST AND BEGAN. IT SAID 'CHK CSD AND RPM AND PERMANENT MAGNET GENERATOR VOLTS. RPM WERE 1100-1200 RPM ABOVE NORMAL. LIMITS ON CSD IS PLUS OR MINUS 400 RPM. CHKLIST SAYS 'IF RPM NOT NORMAL; DISCONNECT CSD.' CAPT WANTED TO TRY TO RESET REGARDLESS OF CSD RPM; OVER MY OBJECTIONS; AND REFS TO CHKLIST AND COMPANY PROCS. I ASKED THE CAPT 'DO YOU REALLY WANT TO DO SOMETHING THAT GOES AGAINST CHKLIST; LIMITATIONS; COMPANY POLICY?' HE SAID; 'YES! TRY AND PUT IT ON LINE. IF IT HOLDS; WE ARE OUT OF HERE. IF NOT WE WILL FOLLOW PROCS.' I AM CHKING WITH CHIEF PLT AS TO WHAT ONE SHOULD DO IN THIS SIT. HE IS THE CAPT; AND WHAT HE SAYS GOES TO AN EXTENT. THAT NIGHT IN MSP; AFTER WRITING THE #2 CSD/GENERATOR UP; MAINT FOUND A FAULTY GENERATOR CTL UNIT AND REPLACED FAULTY UNIT. ALL IS WELL NOW. NEXT TIME; I MIGHT JUST SAY NO! AND TAKE THE CONSEQUENCES. THE FO WAS NO HELP; HE JUST SAT THERE. NO BACK; JUST LET THE CAPT RAMBLE ON AND DO WHAT HE WANTED. I MIGHT SUGGEST THAT ALL CREW MEMBERS PARTICIPATE IN DECISIONS THAT THERE IS TIME TO TALK ABOUT LIKE THIS ONE. I DEFERRED TO CAPT'S AUTH ON THIS DIRECT VIOLATION. THE NEXT DAY I ASKED HIM WHAT WE SHOULD HAVE DONE IN THIS SIT. HE SAID 'JUST WHAT WE DID.' I SAID 'REALLY.' HE SAID;' YOU NEED TO GET FROM POINT A TO POINT B. YOU CAN'T FOLLOW ALL THE REGS OR YOU WOULD NEVER GO FLYING.' I JUST DON'T GET THIS ATTITUDE!!
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.