PVT PLT GETS INTO A CONFRONTATION WITH TWR CHIEF OVER ALLEGED MISHANDLING BY A TWR CTLR THAT PLT JUDGED TO BE 'INEPT.' PLT HAD EXPERIENCED AN NMAC ON DOWNWIND AND ELECTED TO CHANGE LNDG RWY WHEN ANOTHER ACFT TOOK HIS ASSIGNED RWY AT APA.

Date: 1997-08 · Aircraft: Any Unknown or Unlisted Aircraft Manufacturer

Anomalies: conflict-nmac|deviation-track-heading-all-types|deviation-discrepancy-procedural-clearance|other-unspecified

Synopsis

PVT PLT GETS INTO A CONFRONTATION WITH TWR CHIEF OVER ALLEGED MISHANDLING BY A TWR CTLR THAT PLT JUDGED TO BE 'INEPT.' PLT HAD EXPERIENCED AN NMAC ON DOWNWIND AND ELECTED TO CHANGE LNDG RWY WHEN ANOTHER ACFT TOOK HIS ASSIGNED RWY AT APA.

Narrative

I WAS GIVEN INSTRUCTION TO RPT 2 MI L DOWNWIND; AT APA. I WAS IN PATTERN 2.9 MI L DOWN; ACFT APCHING ON STARBOARD. I RPTED TWR POS TO CALL ATTN TO CONFLICT OF ACFT. CTLR ASKED ME; 'WHERE ARE YOU?' I GAVE CTLR CORRECT N NUMBER AND ADVISED 'DOWNWIND RWY 17L.' OTHER PLANE (HIGH WING) PASSED UNDER ME AT 500 FT BELOW. CTLR 'PERMISSION TO LAND; YOU'RE #1.' I TURNED BASE; 500 FT AGL AT 60 KTS AND SAW ACFT ON RWY ON LNDG PATH. I DIVERTED TO RWY 17R AND ADVISED TWR 'ACFT ON RWY DIVERTED TO RWY 17R.' CTLR 'PERMISSION TO LAND.' WHILE ON GND CTL I WAS TOLD TO CALL TWR WHICH I DID AND SPOKE TO MR X; WHO WAS NOT ONLY INCORRECT IN HIS STATEMENTS BUT HOSTILE AS WELL. I CALLED HIS SUPVR AND HE REQUESTED MY NAME AND ADDRESS FOR FSDO. IN MY JUDGEMENT THE TWR PERSON IS IN DESPERATE NEED OF TRAINING AND SHOULD NOT BE IN SUCH A BUSY TWR FOR CTL. SHE COULD NOT KEEP TRACK OF ACFT IN THE AIR; SHE AUTH ACFT TO TKOF WITH ACFT NOT MORE THAN 500 FT AWAY. SHE PERMITTED AN ACFT TO LAND; CLRING ME BY NOT MORE THAN 500 FT UNDERNEATH. SHE COULD NOT REMEMBER THE N NUMBERS OF THE ACFT AND COULD NOT FIND THOSE IN THE PATTERN. I AM REQUESTING A COPY OF THE TAPE OR A COPY OF A TRANSCRIPT OF THE TAPE OF THE PERIOD OF TIME INVOLVED TO VERIFY THIS AND BRING IT TO THE ATTN OF THOSE IN AUTH; TO BE SURE THAT ACTION IS TAKEN TO PREVENT REPETITION.

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.