ACR DC9 ENTERED CTR AIRSPACE AT WRONG ALT AFTER RPTR AND DEVELOPMENTAL CTLR MISSED WRONG ALT READBACK OF 11000 FT VICE 10000 FT BY FLC.
Synopsis
ACR DC9 ENTERED CTR AIRSPACE AT WRONG ALT AFTER RPTR AND DEVELOPMENTAL CTLR MISSED WRONG ALT READBACK OF 11000 FT VICE 10000 FT BY FLC.
Narrative
I WAS WORKING RADAR E CTL POS AND WAS DIRECTLY INVOLVED WITH AN OPDEV IN WHICH A READBACK ERROR OCCURRED. OJT WAS BEING CONDUCTED. I WAS INSTRUCTING. WORKLOAD MODERATE FOR THE DEVELOPMENTAL (TRAINEE) CTLR. ACR X CALLED DEP AIRBORNE (RWY 36); R TURN HDG 040 DEGS; CLBING TO 5000 FT. ACR X WAS RADAR IDENTED; ADVISED 'TURN R HDG 110 DEGS; JOIN VICTOR 2; RESUME OWN NAV; CLB AND MAINTAIN 10000 FT.' ACR X READ BACK THE CLRNC. DURING THE READBACK; THE DEVELOPMENTAL CTLR; WHILE SPEAKING ALOUD; INDICATED THAT SHE MUST INITIATE A POINTOUT TO ZAU LONE ROCK SECTOR AS THIS ACFT WOULD CROSS A STRATIFIED SECTION OF ZAU AIRSPACE APPROX 10 MI WIDE. THE POINTOUT WAS IMMEDIATELY ISSUED AND APPROVED BY THE ZAU CTLR. PRIOR TO ACR X REACHING A CRUISING ALT OF 10000 FT; THE DEVELOPMENTAL CTLR XFERRED RADIO COMS TO MKE APCH AFTER SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETING AN AUTOMATED RADAR HDOF. WITHIN 1-2 MINS OF COM RELEASE; I OBSERVED ACR X AT AN ALT OF 10800 FT AND IMMEDIATELY CONTACTED THE ZAU CTLR WITH REGARDS TO THE DEV. I OBSERVED ACR X LEVEL AT 11000 FT; INFORMED THE ZAU CTLR OF SUCH. HE ADVISED US THAT THE TFC WAS 'ALRIGHT' AND FURTHER DISCUSSION WAS TERMINATED. I PROMPTLY NOTIFIED THE AREA SUPVR IN CHARGE AND WAS RELIEVED OF MY CTL POS. FURTHER REVIEW OF THE AUDIO TAPES INDICATE THAT ACR X PROPERLY READ BACK THE TURN TO 110 DEGS AND TO JOIN THE ASSIGNED AIRWAY; HOWEVER; THE AIR CREW READ BACK AN ASSIGNED ALT OF 11000 INSTEAD OF THE ACTUAL ASSIGNED ALT OF 10000 FT. NEITHER THE DEVELOPMENTAL CTLR; MYSELF; NOR THE SIC (OR PLT; PENDING WHO WAS COMMUNICATING AND WHO WAS FLYING); CAUGHT THE ERROR WHICH LED TO THE DEV. PRIMARY CONTRIBUTING FACTOR: ACR X INITIALLY FILED FOR 11000 FT. BY LOA WITH MKE APCH CTL; MKE ARRS MUST BE AT 7000 FT; 9000 FT; OR 10000 FT. THE ASIC AMENDED THE REQUESTED ALT TO COMPLY WITH THE LOA. OTHER FACTOR: MY FAILURE TO PRIORITIZE PROPERLY -- COMPREHEND READBACKS FIRST; THEN COMPREHENSION OF TRAINEE INTENTIONS TO MAKE THE POINTOUT; AS IN THIS CASE. I PLACED A HIGHER PRIORITY ON THE VERBALLY SPOKEN INTENTION OF FUTURE ACTIONS BY THE DEVELOPMENTAL. MY BELIEF OF THE PROB: AS AN OJT INSTRUCTOR; I HAVE MADE MY PRIORITY; WHILE TRAINING; TO JOT DOWN NOTES AS TOPIC OF DISCUSSION FOR LATER DEBRIEF. NOT HAVING FLT PROGRESS STRIPS DIRECTLY IN FRONT OF ME LEAVES A LARGER THAN DESIRABLE MARGIN OF ERROR. I HAVE NO REF EXCEPT MEMORY (NO JOGGERS) TO AID ME IN THE REMEMBRANCE OF INSTRUCTIONS. BOTTOM LINE -- I MISSED THE READBACK.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.