DFW TCASII RA FIRST GIVES DSCNT THEN QUICKLY CHANGES TO CLB RESOLUTION ON DSCNT INTO DFW.
Synopsis
DFW TCASII RA FIRST GIVES DSCNT THEN QUICKLY CHANGES TO CLB RESOLUTION ON DSCNT INTO DFW.
Narrative
DFW ARR AT 17000 FT. ATC FACILITY: ZFW. LOCATION: ABOUT 25 MI E OF HOWDY INTXN. ON DSCNT THROUGH 17000 FT ON CEDAR CREEK 4 ARR TO DFW ON CEDAR CREEK ARR; WE GOT A TA OF A LEARJET THAT HAD A VISUAL ON US AND HE WOULD MAINTAIN SEPARATION. WE CALLED LOOKING. I SAW AN ACFT AT 9 O'CLOCK. IT WAS NIGHT. TCASII GAVE US A DSND RA AND THEN ALMOST A SECOND LATER A CLB RA. WE SHOWED THE TFC 200 FT BELOW. IN THE CLB I PICKED HIM UP VISUALLY ON R; 5 O'CLOCK. I ALSO SAW ANOTHER ACFT TO OUR L. THIS INCIDENT WAS ALMOST A VERY BIG MESS. I SUGGEST THE FAA NOT ALLOW NIGHT VISUAL SEPARATION. I BELIEVE THE LEAR WAS LOOKING AT ANOTHER ACFT AND NEVER SAW US OR HE IS A COWBOY GETTING WAY TOO CLOSE TO A COMMERCIAL JET. I BELIEVE THE TCASII CAME VERY CLOSE TO CAUSING A DISASTER WHEN IT GAVE THE DSCNT PRIOR TO THE CLB. IF WE HAD REACTED SLIGHTLY FASTER; THERE WOULD HAVE BEEN A MIDAIR. ANOTHER PLT IN COACH DESCRIBED TO US HOW CLOSE IT WAS. HE SAID THE ACFT DID NOT MOVE IN THE WINDOW UNTIL JUST BEFORE IT CLRED BELOW THE TAIL.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.