ACR READS BACK AND FLIES WRONG CLRNC AND CTLR DOES NOT CORRECT IT UNTIL IT IS APPARENT IN THE AIR.
Synopsis
ACR READS BACK AND FLIES WRONG CLRNC AND CTLR DOES NOT CORRECT IT UNTIL IT IS APPARENT IN THE AIR.
Narrative
THE CAPT AND I WERE OPERATING A SCHEDULED FLT FROM ORD TO PHL. WE HAD A NORMAL PUSHBACK AND TAXI FOR TKOF. THERE WAS NO RUSH TO COMPLETE CHKLISTS. WHEN OUR TURN CAME FOR TKOF; WE WERE CLRED BY ORD TWR TO 'POS AND HOLD RWY 22L.' WE WERE THEN GIVEN THE CLRNC: 'TURN L HDG 090 DEGS; RWY 22L CLRED FOR TKOF.' THE CAPT MADE A NORMAL TKOF AND COMPLIED WITH THE L TURN TO A 090 DEG HDG. AFTER ROLLING OUT OF THE TURN; ORD TWR ASKED US WHAT OUR HEADING WAS. I TOLD HIM 'HDG 090 DEGS.' HE IMMEDIATELY ISSUED US A CLRNC TO TURN R TO A 180 DEG HDG; ADDING THAT THE 090 DEG HDG HE ISSUED WAS NOT FOR US; BUT THE ACFT THAT DEPARTED PRIOR TO US. IT WAS OBVIOUS FROM HIS EXCITED TONE OF VOICE THAT HE WAS CONCERNED ABOUT A LOSS OF SEPARATION WITH ANOTHER ACFT. WE IMMEDIATELY COMPLIED WITH THE CLRNC TO TURN R TO HDG 180 DEGS. WE DID NOT RECEIVE ANY TFC OR RA'S FROM OUR TCASII SYS; AND THE TWR CTLR MADE NO MENTION TO US THAT THERE MIGHT HAVE BEEN A LOSS OF SEPARATION. AFTER ANOTHER HEADING CHANGE WE WERE HANDED OFF TO ORD DEP; AND THE FLT CONTINUED NORMALLY. BOTH THE CAPT AND I HAVE NO DOUBT IN OUR MINDS THAT THE ORD TWR CTLR CLRED US TO TURN L TO A 090 DEG HDG WHEN HE CLRED US FOR TKOF. THE TWR CTLR OBVIOUSLY THOUGHT OTHERWISE. AS A PROFESSIONAL PLT; I CAN TELL YOU THAT SUCH OCCURRENCES HAPPEN EVERYDAY AT MAJOR ARPTS. THE WORKLOAD FACED BY CTLRS AND PLTS EVEN DURING 'NORMAL' OPS CAN BE QUITE HVY; THUS INCREASING THE CHANCE FOR MISTAKES. AS CAPACITY ENHANCEMENT TOOLS ARE IMPLEMENTED (LAND AND HOLD SHORT OPS; PRM APCHS; ETC); WORKLOAD AND ERRORS WILL RISE. ALSO DISTURBING IS THE FACT THAT THE FAA HAS RECENTLY ABSOLVED CTLRS FROM THE REQUIREMENT TO CORRECT INCORRECT PLT READBACKS. THIS POLICY IS CLRLY A DETRIMENT TO SAFETY AND IS THE PRIMARY REASON I AM FILING THIS NASA RPT. IT IS GERMANE TO THE SIT DESCRIBED ABOVE. IF OUR READBACK WAS INCORRECT; THE TWR CTLR SHOULD HAVE CORRECTED IT.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.