F100 FLC CONCERNED WITH D10 CTLR BEHAVIOR TRYING TO AVOID WX.

Date: 2000-06 · Aircraft: Fokker 100 · Phase: climb

Anomalies: deviation-track-heading-all-types|deviation-discrepancy-procedural-published-material-policy|inflight-event-encounter-weather-turbulence

Synopsis

F100 FLC CONCERNED WITH D10 CTLR BEHAVIOR TRYING TO AVOID WX.

Narrative

DEPARTED RWY 18L DFW. CONTACTED DEP CTL AND FLEW 185 DEG HDG UNTIL PASSING 4500 FT MSL; THEN A 260 DEG HDG. THERE WAS A RATHER HVY AREA OF PRECIP TO THE WNW OF FUZ VORTAC. AS THE FO AND I WERE CONTEMPLATING OUR NEXT MOVE; AN ACR REQUESTED DEV AROUND WX. THE CTLR REPLIED IN A VERY SARCASTIC TONE THAT NO ONE ELSE SEEMED TO NEED TO DEV 'BUT IF YOU FEEL YOU HAVE TO; I GUESS IT WOULD BE OK.' HE THEN ASKED ANOTHER ACFT IF THEY HAD RECEIVED THE CLRNC HE HAD GIVEN THEM; AND THE FLT REPLIED 'AFFIRMATIVE; WE ACKNOWLEDGED YOU.' THE CTLR SAID 'NO YOU DIDN'T;' OR 'I DIDN'T HEAR YOU.' AT THIS TIME WE WERE WITHIN 5 MI OF THE WX WE WERE HEADING TOWARDS. I ASKED THE CTLR FOR A TURN TO THE NE. 'UNABLE' WAS ALL WE HEARD. I TOLD HIM THAT THE WX TO OUR WNW WAS HVY ENOUGH THAT I DIDN'T WANT TO GO THROUGH IT. HE SAID THAT THE RIDES THROUGH THAT AREA WERE RPTED AS NOT BAD. I TOLD HIM 'I DON'T CARE WHAT EVERYBODY ELSE IS DOING; I DON'T WANT TO GO THROUGH IT.' HIS RESPONSE WAS 'FINE; THEN DO WHAT YOU WANT.' WE TURNED TO ABOUT A 030 DEG HDG AND TOLD THE CTLR THAT WE WOULD INTERCEPT THE FUZ 022 DEG RADIAL AND PROCEED WITH THE DEP. I GUESS THE POINT TO ALL OF THIS IS; WHY WAS THE CTLR SO SHORT WITH NOT ONLY OUR FLT BUT SEVERAL OTHERS? AND IF HE WAS UNABLE TO LET US DEV TO THE NE; THEN WHY THE 'DO WHATEVER YOU WANT' CLRNC? -- IF YOU CAN CALL IT THAT. CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: RPTR BELIEVES THIS INCIDENT WAS ABNORMAL. HE WONDERS WHY THE UNNECESSARY CHALLENGE FOR WX DEV THOUGH. HE PLANS TO ADDRESS FUTURE INCIDENTS AT A HIGHER CORPORATE LEVEL.

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.