A C750 IS OVERTAKEN BY A B737; SAME ALT; SAME DIRECTION; WITH THE B737 GIVEN AN EVASIVE ACTION MANEUVER BY ATC THAT WAS CONTRADICTORY TO THEIR TCASII RA COMMAND HEAR PHL; PA.
Synopsis
A C750 IS OVERTAKEN BY A B737; SAME ALT; SAME DIRECTION; WITH THE B737 GIVEN AN EVASIVE ACTION MANEUVER BY ATC THAT WAS CONTRADICTORY TO THEIR TCASII RA COMMAND HEAR PHL; PA.
Narrative
WHILE ON A VECTOR FOR A VISUAL APCH TO RWY 26 AT PHL; WE HAD AN RA. PHL APCH HAD US ON A 150 DEG HDG AT 6000 FT (LEVEL). A B737 CONVERGED ON US AT APPROX OUR 7 O'CLOCK POS. WE NOTED THE TA ON THE TCASII; BUT THE FO COULD NOT INFORM APCH CTL DUE TO THE VOLUME OF RADIO TFC. THE OTHER ACFT WAS AT OUR ALT AND APPARENTLY MUCH FASTER. WE WERE DOING APPROX 200 KTS. I INFORMED THE FO THAT IT LOOKED LIKE IT WAS GOING TO BE CLOSE. I INITIATED A CLB FOR EVASIVE ACTION JUST BEFORE GETTING A TCASII RA TO CLB. I TOLD THE FO TO NOTIFY APCH THAT WE WERE TAKING EVASIVE ACTION. HE DID SO AND THERE WAS A PERIOD OF SILENCE FROM APCH BEFORE THEY RESPONDED WITH A HDG CHANGE. THE B737 TOOK EVASIVE ACTION AS WELL WITH A R TURN; FOLLOWED BY A HARD L CLBING TURN. THE ATC CTLR GAVE US A 200 DEG HDG AND NOTHING WAS SAID ABOUT THE INCIDENT FROM ATC. I CALLED THE APCH CTL SUPVR AFTER LNDG AND HE ADVISED ME THAT THE CTLR HAD COME TO HIM AND SAID 'A COUPLE GOT TANGLED UP OUT THERE;' AT WHICH POINT THEY BEGAN PULLING THE TAPES. THE ATC SUPVR INFORMED ME AT THAT TIME THAT THE ATC ALARMS WENT OFF WHEN THE 2 ACFT WERE AT 200 FT AND 1.72 NM FROM EACH OTHER. APCH CTL QUALITY ASSURANCE PERSONNEL TOLD ME IN A LATER TELEPHONE CALL THAT IT WAS CTLR ERROR. THEY INFORMED ME THAT THE OTHER ACFT AS 100 KTS FASTER AND WAS BEING VECTORED ON A DIFFERENT FREQ; WHILE WE HAD BEEN SWITCHED TO THE FINAL CTLR. HE ALSO STATED THAT ATC GAVE THE B737 AN EVASIVE MANEUVER VECTOR AND CLB THAT CONFLICTED WITH THE B737 RA FROM TCASII. A CTLR CHANGE (RELIEF) WAS ALSO IN PROGRESS THAT MAY HAVE CONTRIBUTED TO THE CONFLICT.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.