C414 FO COMMENTS THE NEW TWR THE FAA IS BUILDING AT CMH IS 50 FT ABOVE THE DECISION HT FOR ALL ILS APCHS.
Synopsis
C414 FO COMMENTS THE NEW TWR THE FAA IS BUILDING AT CMH IS 50 FT ABOVE THE DECISION HT FOR ALL ILS APCHS.
Narrative
THIS WAS A NORMAL FLT UNTIL WE GOT TO THE BOTTOM OF THE ILS. APPARENTLY; THE RABBIT WAS NOT ON; AT LAST WE HAD TO MISS AND THE ACR BEHIND US DID TOO; THEN THEY STARTED TO GET IN AGAIN WHEN THE SUN WENT DOWN. THE CONCERN IS THE NEW CTL TWR; WHICH IS NOT YET COMMISSIONED. THE TWR IS BTWN THE RWYS; JUST BEYOND MID-FIELD FROM RWYS 10L/R. THE RWYS ARE (GUESSTIMATE) 1500-2000 FT APART. THE TOP OF THE TWR IS (GET THIS) 50 FT ABOVE THE DECISION HT FOR ALL 4 RWYS. ON MAR/SUN/02; I WAS THE GUY IN THE R SEAT; AND WHEN THERE WAS NO RWY TO BE FOUND; I RECOMMENDED MISSED APCH; WITH VIGOR; SINCE THE NEW CTL TWR WAS MIGHTY CLOSE. MY REASON FOR WRITING IS TO EXPRESS CONCERN OVER THE NEW TWR. I AM NOW; THANKFULLY; AN OLD CFI. YOU AND I KNOW HOW EASY IT IS TO MAKE A MISSED APCH AND NOT REALLY CLB ALL THAT MUCH FOR SEVERAL SECONDS. THE LOC BEAM GETS NARROWER AND THE WHOLE MIND SET MUST CHANGE ON A MISSED APCH; SO IT IS NOT AT ALL UNUSUAL TO SEE A DRIFTING TO THE L OR R. WORSE YET; SINGLE ENG ACFT HAVE A NATURAL L TURNING TENDENCY THAT IS EASILY FORGOTTEN AMID ALL THE NOISE AND CLB AND CHANGE OF PLANS. WHY ARE THE APCHS AT CMH STILL AT 200 FT WITH A TWR NEARBY AT 250 FT? I RECALL THERE ARE OBSTACLE LIMITS FOR VARIOUS CATEGORIES OF ACFT; BASED ON APCH SPD. I WOULD BE SURPRISED IF THIS TWR DOESN'T BUST CATEGORY A. SOMEBODY IS GOING TO HIT THAT CUMULO-CONCRETE IN THE CLOUDS; BUT IT IS NOT GOING TO BE ME. EITHER THE TWR WILL HAVE TO BE LOWERED OR THE APCHS WILL HAVE TO BE RAISED; WHICH IS NO FUN BECAUSE THE TWR SURE LOOKS GREAT TO ALL THE PAX; AND THE AIRLINES MIGHT NOT LIKE DIVERTING ALL THE TIME. CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: THE TWR SUPVR STATED THE TWR HT IS 210 FT ABOVE THE ARPT. IT COMPLIES WITH ALL TERPS CRITERIA AND WILL NOT AFFECT THE MINIMUMS FOR THE ILS APCHS.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.