AN ACR PLT QUESTIONS HIS COMPANY'S POLICY OF AUTOTHRUST USE IN THE AIRBUS 319 ACFT DURING GUSTY SURFACE WIND CONDITIONS DURING THE APCH AND LNDG MANEUVER.

Narrative

ON APR/MON/02; I WAS FLYING AN AIRBUS 319 ACFT; FROM ROC TO PHL. APCHING THE PHL AREA; MY FO AND I DISCUSSED THE SURFACE WINDS; WHICH WERE GUSTING TO 30 KTS OUT OF THE NW. WE ELECTED TO UTILIZE THE COMPANY RECOMMENDED PROCS FOR LNDG THE AIRBUS 319 IN GUSTY SURFACE WIND CONDITIONS. SO; WE UTILIZED A 'FLAP 3 DEG' CONFIGN FOR LNDG AND 'VAPP' WAS 10 KTS ABOVE THE 'VLS' SPD. JUST AFTER XING THE END OF THE RWY; AT APPROX 40 FT ABOVE THE GND; I HAD JUST BEGUN TO MOVE THE THRUST LEVERS OUT OF THE CLB DETENT BACK TOWARD THE IDLE DETENT. SUDDENLY; THE AIRPLANE SETTLED RAPIDLY TOWARD THE RWY. ALTHOUGH THERE WAS STILL A WIDE RANGE OF AUTOTHRUST AUTH STILL AVAILABLE; THE AUTOTHRUST SYS FAILED TO RESPOND; SO I MANUALLY SELECTED 'TOGA' THRUST WITH THE THRUST LEVERS AND MANAGED TO ARREST THE DSCNT SUFFICIENTLY TO AVOID A 'HARD' LNDG; BUT IT WAS DEFINITELY A FIRM LNDG WITH A SLIGHT BOUNCE. ONE OF OUR FLT ATTENDANT RPTED SOME SLIGHT BACK PAIN; AS A RESULT OF THE ACFT TOUCHING DOWN SLIGHTLY MISALIGNED; AS A RESULT OF A PREMATURE TOUCHDOWN. IT IS MY BELIEF THAT AIRLINE PROCS REQUIRING THE USE OF AUTOTHRUST FOR ALL REGIMES OF FLT; INCLUDING LNDGS; RESULTED IN THIS MARGINALLY SAFE/UNSAFE SIT; RESULTING IN THE ACFT BEING TEMPORARILY OUT OF CTL. ORDINARILY; A PLT HAS COMPLETE AND IMMEDIATE THRUST CTL THROUGH ALL REGIMES OF FLT; BUT NOT HERE AT ACR X. PREVIOUS ACCIDENTS WITH THE AIRBUS SERIES OF ACFT BEAR OUT THAT GUSTY WIND LNDGS ARE A PROB WITH THE ACFT; PRIMARILY BECAUSE OF THE WAY THAT IT IS MANDATED TO BE FLOWN. IT IS MY SUGGESTION THAT THE FOLLOWING PROC (THE '20/10' RULE) TO BE USED: I SUGGEST THAT WHEN THE SURFACE WINDS ARE ABOVE 20 KTS; EITHER GUSTING OR STEADY STATE; AND THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BTWN THE STEADY STATE WIND AND THE GUSTS OF MORE THAN 10 KTS; THAT PLTS THEN BE ALLOWED TO DISCONNECT THE AUTOTHRUST SYS BY 1000 FT AGL; AND CTL THE THRUST MANUALLY; SO AS TO HAVE MORE IMMEDIATE RESPONSE AND CTL. IT IS MY UNDERSTANDING THAT OTHER ACR'S ALLOW THEIR AIRBUS CREWS TO MANUALLY CTL THE THRUST OF THE ACFT. IT IS MY HOPE THAT ACR X MAY RECOGNIZE THAT THE AUTOTHRUST SYS MAY NOT BE ABLE TO 'KEEP UP' IN SOME LLWS CONDITIONS; AND TO ALLOW THE PLTS TO 'FLY THE ACFT.' AFTER ALL; ISN'T THAT WHY WE ARE THERE IN THE FIRST PLACE? CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: COMPANY POLICY IS THE RECOMMENDED USE OF AUTOTHRUST FOR ALL APCHS REGARDLESS OF WIND CONDITIONS. THE EXIT FROM AUTOTHRUST; IF DETERMINED TO BE NECESSARY BY THE PLT; IS LIMITED TO THE SELECTION OF TOGA (TKOF/GAR) THRUST WHICH GIVES FULL THRUST AUTH BACK TO THE PLT BUT BEGINS WITH MAX THRUST MAKING IT A VERY CONVOLUTED MANEUVER WITH POSSIBLY MORE THAN THE REQUIRED THRUST INITIALLY. THERE IS NO GUST FACTOR ADDED TO THE REF SPD WHEN GUSTY WINDS ARE PRESENT. THE ACFT AUTOFLT SYS RESTRICTS PITCH IF AIRSPD IS LOW. THE UNION TRAINING COMMITTEE HAS MADE AN EFFORT TO CONVINCE THE COMPANY TO CHANGE THE AUTOTHRUST POLICY DUE TO MANY PLT COMPLAINTS. TO DATE THERE HAS BEEN NO RESPONSE FROM THE COMPANY.