CAPT OF DC10 IN RVSM AIRSPACE INITIATES INAPPROPRIATE AVOIDANCE MANEUVER BASED ON TCASII TA. NO RA RECEIVED.
Synopsis
CAPT OF DC10 IN RVSM AIRSPACE INITIATES INAPPROPRIATE AVOIDANCE MANEUVER BASED ON TCASII TA. NO RA RECEIVED.
Narrative
ENRTE TO CHITOSE; JAPAN AT FL290 WHILE IN JAPAN AIRSPACE; CTLR ADVISED US OF TFC SE OF OUR POS MOVING E TO W AND WOULD BE CLBING TO FL280 ALLOWING A 1000 FT SEPARATION. WE WERE IMC IN LEVEL FLT. I SAW TFC AS RPTED DEPICTED ON THE TCASII SCREEN AND CONSISTENT WITH WHAT THE CTLR SAID. I LOOKED AT THE VSI/RA DISPLAY ONBOARD AND SAW THE RPTED TFC AS A HOLLOW WHITE TRIANGLE CLBING. I THEN LOOKED OUT THE WINDOW IN SAME DIRECTION TO TRY TO GET A VISUAL ON TFC. SINCE WE WERE STILL IMC I LOOKED BACK AT VSI/RESOLUTION DISPLAY AND THE SYMBOL HAD TURNED TO SOLID WHITE DIAMOND (NON-THREAT TFC) STILL TO OUR SE POS AND CLBING. ABOUT THAT TIME THE CAPT DISCONNECTED THE AUTOPLT; STARTED A CLBING TURN ON AN E HDG AND FLEW UP TO APPROX FL310. SIMULTANEOUSLY HE DEMANDED I CALL CTL AND NOTIFY THEM OF DEV FOR TFC. I DID NOT SEE THE TFC OUT THE WINDOW NOR DID I SEE AN RA ON THE DISPLAY AND AT NO TIME WAS AN AUDIO COMMAND GIVEN BY THE TCASII. PREVENTIVE/CORRECTIVE ACTION: I BELIEVE THAT THE CAPT OVERREACTED. HE MAY NOT HAVE PROCESSED WHAT THE CTLR SAID AND/OR UNDERSTAND THE ONBOARD TCASII DISPLAY. I BELIEVE THE CAPT SHOULD REVIEW RVSM AIRSPACE; THE TCASII SYS AND ITS SYMBOLOGY/AUDIO FUNCTIONS. I AM AT A LOSS AS TO WHY HE CHOSE TO TURN INTO THE TFC PATH OF AN ACFT HE DEEMED TO BE A THREAT.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.