MINOR DAMAGE RESULTS WHEN SIMULATED LOW ALT ENG FAILURE OF C182RG RESULTS IN HARD LNDG.
Synopsis
MINOR DAMAGE RESULTS WHEN SIMULATED LOW ALT ENG FAILURE OF C182RG RESULTS IN HARD LNDG.
Narrative
I WAS GIVING THE PIC A STANDARDIZATION RIDE. I REQUESTED THE PIC TO PERFORM A SHORT FIELD TKOF. AT APPROX 100 FT AGL; I PULLED THE PWR BACK AND ANNOUNCED; 'SIMULATED ENG FAILURE.' PIC PULLED THE NOSE UP (WHICH I SOMEWHAT EXPECTED; AS I DO THIS MANEUVER IN EVERY CHK RIDE I GIVE AND ALL PLTS TEND TO DO THIS). WHAT I WAS ONLY PERIPHERALLY AWARE OF IS THAT THE PIC HAD RETRACTED THE LNDG GEAR; WHICH I REALIZED WHEN I HEARD THE LNDG GEAR WARNING HORN. I IMMEDIATELY LOWERED THE GEAR. HOWEVER; DURING THIS TIME THE ACFT DEVELOPED A HIGH SINK RATE. I TOLD THE PLT TO LOWER THE NOSE AND ADD PWR; WHICH THE PIC DID; BUT IT WAS 'TOO LITTLE; TOO LATE.' WE BOUNCED ONCE ON THE RWY; THEN BOUNCED ON ONE MAIN; THEN THE OTHER; WHILE DRIFTING TOWARD THE L SIDE OF THE RWY. DURING ONE OF THE BOUNCES; THE ACFT STRUCK A RWY LIGHT (IMPACT ON THE L HORIZ STABILIZER CAUSING 2 SMALL GASHES IN THE SKIN). I TOOK CTL OF THE ACFT AND TAXIED OFF THE RWY AND TO THE RAMP WITHOUT FURTHER INCIDENT. IN RETROSPECT; I SHOULD HAVE DONE SEVERAL THINGS DIFFERENTLY: 1) WHEN I REALIZED THE GEAR WAS UP; I SHOULD HAVE ABORTED THE MANEUVER. I THINK I WAS FOCUSING ON THE FACT THAT THE PIC HAD MOVED HIS HAND FROM THE THROTTLE; ALLOWING ME TO PULL THE PWR. 2) I CERTAINLY SHOULD HAVE ANNOUNCED 'MY PLANE' AND TAKEN THE CTLS MUCH SOONER. I TREAT THIS AS A 'LEARNING' MANEUVER FOR MY STUDENTS -- NOT A 'TESTING' ONE. MY INTENT IS FOR THE PLT TO LEARN TO ADJUST THE PITCH TO CTL THE AIRSPD; NOT AUTOMATICALLY PULL BACK ON THE YOKE. ONCE THE PIC HAD MADE HIS MISTAKE OF DOING THAT; MY POINT WOULD HAVE BEEN MADE EVEN IF I HAD TAKEN CTL AT THAT TIME. I SUPPOSE I WAS WALKING THE FINE LINE (THAT INSTRUCTORS DO) BTWN GIVING THE OTHER PLT ENOUGH 'ROPE' TO CORRECT MISTAKES ON THEIR OWN VERSUS ALLOWING A DANGEROUS SITUATION TO DEVELOP. A CONTRIBUTING FACTOR WAS THE FACT THAT DURING MY CHK PLT CHK RIDE LAST MONTH; THE 'CHK-CHK-PLT' OBSERVED I WAS TAKING CTL (FROM THOSE BEING CHKED) TOO SOON UPON MISTAKES. PERHAPS THAT CAUSED ME TO WAIT A LITTLE LONGER TO TAKE CTL.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.