ZFW CTLR EXPRESSED CONCERN REGARDING THE NOTAM DISPLAY AND DISPERSAL SYSTEM USED IN THE CTL ROOM.
Synopsis
ZFW CTLR EXPRESSED CONCERN REGARDING THE NOTAM DISPLAY AND DISPERSAL SYSTEM USED IN THE CTL ROOM.
Narrative
MVFR CONDITIONS IN OKC AREA -- WORKING ZFW AIRSPACE ADJACENT TO OKC APCH. WEST SIDE -- OKC HANDS OFF ACFT X; AN IFR MOONEY LNDG HINTON; OK; (2O8). ON INITIAL CONTACT; ACFT X REQUESTED RNAV35 INTO 2O8. SINCE IT WAS MVFR AT OKC I PULLED THE APCH PLATE 'BINDER' TO REVIEW THE PLATE. THE CHART HAD A SMALL SLIP OF PAPER OVERLYING THE CHART; WHICH IS HOW OUR AIRSPACE OFFICE USUALLY DISPLAYS NOTAMS ON APCHES. READING THE NOTAM -- THE WORDING 'ORIG...PROC NA' MADE NO SENSE TO ME I ASKED 4 OTHER CTLRS WHAT IT MEANT TO THEM AND NO ONE KNEW. I SUBSEQUENTLY CLRED ACFT X FOR THE APCH -- TO MAINTAIN AT OR ABOVE 3500 FT UNTIL IAF. SO THE ACFT X IS MANEUVERING TOWARDS THE IAF AT 3500 FT WHEN I ASK ANOTHER CTLR WHO IS A CFII WHAT HE THOUGHT THE NOTAM MEANT. HE SAID IT MEANT WHAT IT SAID -- ORIGINAL NOT AVAILABLE. I IMMEDIATELY CANCELLED ACFT X'S CLRNC AND CLBED HIM BACK TO THE MINIMUM RADAR ALT OF 4000 FT. WHEN I TOLD HIM THE APCH WAS NOTAMED NOT AVAIL -- THE PLT SAID; 'OH -- I KNEW IT WAS. I THOUGHT IT MIGHT BE USABLE THOUGH.' I WRITE THIS EVENT UP BECAUSE I FEEL THE SYSTEM AT ZFW FOR APCH NOTAMS IS LACKING. THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT FOR CTLRS TO CONSULT OUR CHART BINDERS BEFORE CLRNCS ISSUED. JUST BE UP-TO-DATE WITH NOTAMS ON BRIEFING BOARD AT SECTOR. THIS NOTAM WAS NOT ON THE BOARD NOR WAS IT ON THE LIST KEPT CURRENT AT THE SUPVR DESK. I STRONGLY FEEL THAT IF AN APCH IS DEEMED UNUSABLE -- THE CHART SHOULD EITHER BE REMOVED OR A CLEARLY WRITTEN AND POSSIBLY VISUALLY SIGNIFICANT (LIKE A RED X OR SOMETHING) NOTE SHOULD LEAVE NO DOUBT THAT AN APCH IS NOTAMED OUT. ALSO -- CLEAR EMPHASIS SHOULD BE ADDED THAT CTLRS SHOULD REVIEW APCH PLATES PRIOR TO ANY MVFR OR LOWER CLRNC ISSUED TO DOUBLE CHK THAT SOMEONE FORGOT TO WRITE DOWN A NOTAM LIKE THIS ONE.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.