INADVERTENT PENTRATION OF TCA ON DUAL CROSS-COUNTRY FLT.
Synopsis
INADVERTENT PENTRATION OF TCA ON DUAL CROSS-COUNTRY FLT.
Narrative
WE DEPARTED TEB XB AM LCL; ENRTE HTO FOR LNDG AT E HAMPTON. I WAS IN THE R SEAT AS CFI; THE STUDENT IN L SEAT FOR HER THIRD DUAL X-COUNTRY; PRIOR TO X-COUNTRY SIGN OFF. I PRIDE MYSELF ON GIVING CLR TCA AVOIDANCE TRNING TO STUDENTS; SO IT IS WITH SOME CHAGRIN I ADMIT TO POSSIBLY ENTERING TCA SPACE W/O PERMISSION. THE KEY ISSUE FOR ME IS NONETHELESS I AM NOT SURE AN INCURSION OCCURRED. I SHOULD BE. WE PROCEEDED E OVER THE HUDSON AT 1000' (IE; BELOW TCA AT 1100') TO PASS GWB; HDG N; CLBED TO 1400' (BELOW TCA AT 1500'); TUNED AND IDENTED CCC R290 AND BEGAN TRACKING INBND. I USED THIS R TO ASSURE CTL ZONE AVOIDANCE AT WESTCHESTER; AND TCA AVOIDANCE AT LGA. INTERCEPTION OF THIS R ALLOWS CLB TO 2900' (BELOW TCA AT 3000'). HOWEVER; THE STUDENT TRACKED R OF COURSE 2 1/2 DOTS; SO AT 200'/DOT/NM; THAT PUT US ABOUT 4 NM S OF DESIRED TRACK OR PERHAPS BACK INTO THE TCA SECTION NE LGA WITH A BASE OF 1500'. I IMMEDIATELY UPON THIS REALIZATION DIRECTED STUDENT TO TURN L TO REINTERCEPT CCC R290 AND TRACK INBND WE WERE CLBING OUT OF 2000' TO 2900'. NOW HERE'S MY SAFETY ISSUE. I LET MYSELF BE DISTR BY THE POSSIBLE INCURSION INTO THE TCA; SO I DIRECTED MY ATTN TO THE R SIDE OF THE CRAFT TO IDENT LANDMARKS TO ASCERTAIN MY EXACT POS. MEANWHILE WE HAD ARRIVED S OF WESTCHESTER CO AND A HVY ACFT WAS ABOVE AND TO THE L HIDDEN BY THE L HIGH WING FROM THE STUDENT. WE WERE LEVEL AT 2900' (BELOW TCA AT 3000'). I TOOK THE CRAFT OVER; DSNDED R TO ASSURE ADEQUATE CLRNC. THE REST OF THE FLT PROCEEDED QUITE WELL; AND I DEBRIEFED THE STUDENT ABOUT THIS EVENT IMMEDIATELY UPON LNDG AT EAST HAMPTON. SHE WAS SURE WE HADN'T ENTERED TCA; BUT I WASN'T AND LET MYSELF BE DISTR IN ANY CASE FROM PRIMARY SEE AND AVOID ISSUES. TEACHING PRIMARY STUDENTS CAN BE A WORKLOAD OF ITS OWN. COMBINE THAT WITH TCA AVOIDANCE; AND ANTI-COLLISION AVOIDANCE IN A BUSY AIRSPACE AND I REALIZE THERE ARE SAFETY ISSUES I HAD NOT EXPLORED BEFORE. IN THE FUTURE; I WILL BE MORE SPECIFIC ABOUT PT TO PT GND CHKPOINTS TO ASSURE TCA AVOIDANCE RATHER THAN RADIAL TRACK AVOIDANCE ALONE. I WILL USE DME-ARC INFO. I WILL NOT LET NOTHING DISTR ME FROM PRIMARY SEE AND AVOID CONCERNS. I WILL USE FLT FOLLOWING AS AVAILABLE IN ALL CONGESTED AREAS; AND TEACH MY STUDENTS MORE CLRLY ITS USES (EVEN IF STUDENTS CANNOT REQUEST ENTRY THEY WILL LATER!) I WILL SHARE THIS EXPERIENCE WITH MY STUDENTS TO INCREASE THEIR DILIGENCE AND HELP THEM REALIZE POSSIBLE SOURCES OF DISTR FROM SAFETY ISSUES. CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO. RPTR QUESTIONS THAT HE WAS ACTUALLY IN THE TCA. NO FOLLOW-UP FROM CTLR AND THE FAA HAS NOT BEEN CONTACTED. WAS DISTR DURING THE INCURSION EXPLAINING TO THE STUDENT THE PROPER METHOD OF INTERCEPTING A RADIAL. ACR TFC WAS REALLY NOT A FACTOR.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.