IFR aircraft on visual approach to Runway XX experienced conflict with flight of two VFR aircraft on low approach to Runway XY; reporter alleged ATC's separation planning was flawed causing the event.
Synopsis
IFR aircraft on visual approach to Runway XX experienced conflict with flight of two VFR aircraft on low approach to Runway XY; reporter alleged ATC's separation planning was flawed causing the event.
Narrative
ATC asked what type approach I was requesting. I advised; 'Request Visual XX'. Winds on the ATIS were less than 4 KTS; and ATIS was advising Runway's XY & XZ in use. ATC said; 'contact Tower' about 10NM out; I requested a Visual XX. Tower advised 'Plan Visual XX; contact Tower 4NM out'. At 4NM I contacted Tower with my altitude and they cleared me straight in Visual XX. Tower was also talking to a flight of 2 experimental aircraft doing a low approach on Runway XY. The flight of 2 confirmed their low approach and plans to depart straight out. The flight of 2 turned NORTH on a 'conflict' course with my IFR visual clearance for a straight in visual XX. Tower advised a flight of 2 experimental aircraft had turned north and were at 1;200 FT. That is pattern altitude and exactly where I was at. I immediately advised starting a decent below pattern altitude to 'avoid' the conflicting traffic; and started a decent to 1;000 FT. In the decent I located the flight of 2... BELOW ME AT 1;000 FT. I immediately climbed to avoid them. We came within 0.1NM of each other and 100' vertically. On the ground I contacted Tower by telephone and advised them of the near-miss. I also told them that I was the priority aircraft on an Instrument Clearance Visual XX. And told Tower they should have instructed the VFR experimental flight of 2 to depart straight out XY; which would have insured no-conflict. The tower operator told me the flight of 2 had told him they would depart 340; paralleling my inbound course of 160.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.