MLG BUSTED CROSSING RESTRICTION AT KARYN INTERSECTION. PLT PHRASEOLOGY 'UNRESTRICTED CLIMB' NOT CAUGHT BY DEP CTLR.
Synopsis
MLG BUSTED CROSSING RESTRICTION AT KARYN INTERSECTION. PLT PHRASEOLOGY 'UNRESTRICTED CLIMB' NOT CAUGHT BY DEP CTLR.
Narrative
THE F/O WAS FLYING THE POMONA 1 DEP OUT OF ONT. THERE IS A 7000' ALT RESTRICTION AT KARYN INTXN; 2 NM FROM POMONO VOR. THERE WAS A VERY CAREFUL BRIEFING OF THE DEP AND 7000' WAS SET IN THE ALT ALERT WINDOW. WHEN WE WERE HANDED OFF TO DEP CTL FROM ONT TWR; THE DEP CTLR CLRED US TO 12000'. I READ BACK THAT WE WERE CLRED UNRESTRICTED TO CLB TO 12000' VERY SLOWLY AND CAREFULLY; SINCE THAT WAS VERY UNUSUAL FOR DEP CTL TO ISSUE THAT DELETION OF THE ALT RESTRICTION. THE READBACK WAS AS FOLLOWS: 'UNDERSTAND CLB UNRESTRICTED TO 12000?' THE CTLR REPLIED; 'ROGER.' AT ABOUT 7800' MSL THE CTLR QUESTIONED OUR ALT AND TOLD US TO DSND TO 7000'. THEN HE CHANGED HIS MIND AND TOLD US TO CONTINUE TO 12000'. AT THAT TIME I MADE SEVERAL COMMENTS ABOUT HIM JUST PREVIOUSLY CLRING US UNRESTRICTED TO 12000' AND THAT I HAD READ BACK THE CLRNC VERY SLOWLY AND CAREFULLY; EXPRESSING SURPRISE IN MY VOICE THAT HE HAD GIVEN US THAT CLRNC IN THE FIRST PLACE. THE I STATED THAT HE BETTER READ BACK THE TAPE IF HE HAD ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT MY CAREFUL AND SLOW READBACK OF HIS UNRESTRICTED CLRNC. I CAN'T THINK OF ANY POSSIBLE WAY OF PREVENTING A FUTURE OCCURRENCE EXCEPT TO IGNORE THE DELETION OF THE RESTRICTION AND FLY THE PUBLISHED ALT PROFILE INSTEAD. I COULDN'T POSSIBLY HAVE MADE THE FACT THAT THE RESTRICTION WAS MORE CLR W/O REPEATING MYSELF SEVERAL TIMES. THE ONLY OTHER POSSIBILITY IS FOR THEM NOT TO ISSUE A CLRNC ABOVE 7000' UNTIL PAST KARYN.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.