MRI controller elected not to issue go around instructions to landing traffic with an aircraft clearing the landing runway because of multiple previous landing attempts by the landing aircraft; the reporter noting an anxious pilot who needed to land.

Date: 2010-03 · Aircraft: DA20-C1 Eclipse · Phase: landing

Anomalies: atc-issue-all-types|deviation-discrepancy-procedural-published-material-policy

Synopsis

MRI controller elected not to issue go around instructions to landing traffic with an aircraft clearing the landing runway because of multiple previous landing attempts by the landing aircraft; the reporter noting an anxious pilot who needed to land.

Narrative

Prior to Aircraft X contacting Merrill (MRI) inbound to the field; FBO requested we sequence Aircraft X into Runway 34. I sequenced Aircraft X into Runway 34. Aircraft X extended left base into Lake Hood's (LHD) airspace and I/we attempted to coordinate with LHD. I instructed Aircraft X to turn left base as the aircraft appeared to fly a more 'U' shaped pattern which placed the aircraft in LHD's airspace. On short final Aircraft X stated going around. I gave Aircraft X the wind 010 at 7 knots and a left turn entry for Runway 7 or 34 per their request. After no response I sequenced and cleared Aircraft X to land on Runway 7 or 34 and I gave the aircraft the wind again and asked which runway was preferred. Aircraft X came in high and fast on final again for Runway 34 and went around again. I gave Aircraft X the wind and runway choice again. Aircraft X flew through Runway 7 final and I asked Aircraft X if they would follow Aircraft Y for Runway 7. Aircraft X stated yes and followed Aircraft Y. Though I knew Aircraft Y would not be clear of Runway 7 before Aircraft X crossed the threshold; I purposely did not send Aircraft X around and I stated so to all cab personnel because I felt it was the safest operation to have Aircraft X land without incident versus get more anxious as the pilot was already stressed. Recommendation; I could have sent Aircraft X around again to have adequate spacing. However; I know if I were presented with the same scenario I would again do the same by allowing Aircraft X to land. I do not like to bend the rules but I do see the benefit my choice had for Aircraft X.

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.