ACR LGT COMPLETED A CAT III APCH TO A NON CAT III RWY.
Synopsis
ACR LGT COMPLETED A CAT III APCH TO A NON CAT III RWY.
Narrative
THROUGH OVERSIGHT ON MY PART I DID NOT SEE NOTAM THAT PHL RWY 9R CAT II/III CERTIFICATION HAD BEEN LOST AND THAT APCH WOULD BE REMOVED DURING FUTURE COMMERCIAL CHART REVISIONS. MY REVISIONS WERE CURRENT AND STILL HAD ILS RWY 9R CAT II/III PLATE. BEFORE IN RANGE PHASE OF FLT MY CREW REVIEWED CAT II AUTOLAND PROC AND USED ALL CAT III CHKLISTS AND PROCS THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE APCH AND LNDG. THE AUTOLAND WORKED OUT VERY NICELY WITH VIS AND CEILING BEING BETTER AT 100' THAN RPTED. ROLLOUT MAY HAVE BEEN ABOUT AS RPTED. ON LNDG TWR ASKED IF WE SAW APCH LIGHTS AND QUESTIONED THEIR LIGHT MONITOR. SINCE CAT III CONDITIONS USUALLY DON'T INVOLVE SIGHTING OF APCH LIGHTS DURING DAYLIGHT; ESPECIALLY INTO THE SUN; I DISMISSED ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS AS NORMAL CONDITIONS. IT WAS NOT UNTIL THE NEXT DAY THAT I WAS DISCUSSING PHL AND OTHER EAST COAST WX WITH ANOTHER PLT THAT I CHKED NOTAMS ON PHL AND DISCOVERED MY OVERSIGHT. I GENERALLY CHK NOTAMS AND PHYSICALLY CHK ITEMS AS I READ THEM. OUR FLT PAPERS ARE USUALLY FOLDED ACCORDION STYLE ALONG TEAR LINES FOR NEATNESS IN OPS AND I MAY HAVE SKIPPED ONE FOLD AS I REVIEWED THE 3 OR 4' OF PAPERS. IN RETROSPECT I SHOULD HAVE REVIEWED NOTAMS DURING FLT WHEN WX DID NOT IMPROVE. LOW ALT CENTER ADVISED US OF PHL WX BEFORE HANDING US OFF TO PHL RAPCON. PHL APCH ASKED US IF WE COULD MAKE THE #1 APCH. WE SAID YES. THE SAME NUMBER IS USED FOR STD ILS AND CAT II/III APCH PLATES. ASIDE FROM MY PERSONAL OVERSIGHT I BELIEVE ATIS SHOULD MENTION STATUS OF FACS IF APPROPRIATE TO WX CONDITIONS; AND AS A BACKUP; NO APCH PLATES SHOULD HAVE THE SAME IDENT NUMBERS; IE; BASIC CAT I PLATE AND CAT II-III PLATE FOR SAME RWY SHOULD BE CALLED BY DIFFERENT TERMINOLOGY BY ATIS AND RAPCON. AS A SIDE THOUGHT; NO OTHER ACFT; TO MY KNOWLEDGE; WERE ON RAPCON FREQ EXCEPT AN ACR Y MLG HOLDING FOR 1200' RVR.
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.