LESS THAN STANDARD SEPARATION BETWEEN SMA AND CORP-JET. BOTH IFR DEP FROM SAME RWY. OPERATIONAL ERROR.

Date: 1988-11 · Aircraft: Small Aircraft; High Wing; 1 Eng; Fixed Gear

Anomalies: atc-issue-all-types|conflict-airborne-conflict

Synopsis

LESS THAN STANDARD SEPARATION BETWEEN SMA AND CORP-JET. BOTH IFR DEP FROM SAME RWY. OPERATIONAL ERROR.

Narrative

I WAS WORKING LCL CTL WITH A TRNEE. SMA X WAS CLRED FOR TKOF ON RWY 35 WITH A RIGHT TURN TO A HDG OF 020 DEGS WHEN X WAS ABOUT 2 MI N CORP JET Y WAS CLRED FOR TKOF WITH A RIGHT TURN TO 040 DEGS. BOTH ACFT WERE IFR AND ASSIGNED 4000'. WHEN Y WAS AT THE N BOUNDARY THE TRNEE INSTRUCTED Y TO START HIS RIGHT TURN TO 040 DEGS NOW. HE WAITED UNTIL Y WAS ESTABLISHED ON THE HDG BEFORE SWITCHING CORP Y TO DEP CTL. HE WAS USING PARAGRAPH 5-113 OF 7110.65E FOR SEP (1 MI IF COURSES DIVERGE IMMEDIATELY AFTER DEP). THE DEP CTLR ON INITIAL CONTACT TURNED Y TO A HDG OF 360 DEGS. THIS NEGATED THE SEP WE HAD ESTABLISHED AND CAUSED Y TO PASS 1/4 MI TO THE LEFT OF X AND AT THE SAME ALT. I THINK THE DEP CTLR THOUGHT BOTH ACFT WERE ON THE SALEM HDG AND Y WAS GOING TO CATCH X WHEN OUR LCL PROCS REQUIRED X TO BE ASSIGNED 020 DEGS ON Y TO BE ASSIGNED 040 DEGS. CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING: TRNEE HAD PUT CORP Y INTO TKOF POS IMMEDIATELY BEHIND SMA X TKOF ROLL WITH INTENTION OF HAVING Y TKOF AND TURN INSIDE OF X WITH VISUAL SEP APPLIED. PLAN DID NOT WORK BECAUSE CORP Y WAS IN TWR FREQ BLIND SPOT ON RWY AND COULD NOT HEAR TKOF CLRNC. PLT OF Y RECOGNIZED PROB AND MOVED FORWARD ON RWY OUT OF BLIND SPOT; BUT BY THAT TIME VIS SEP NO LONGER FEASIBLE. WE DISCUSSED HOW SEP PLAN OF TRNEE DID NOT MEET ATC PROC HANDBOOK CRITERIA. RPTR AGREED. THERE WAS STRONG WIND FROM N. AUS TRACON HAS ARTSS II RADAR AND SO DOES NOT HAVE C/A. FAC REVIEW FOUND LCL CTLR DID NOT PROVIDE REQUIRED INITIAL SEP. SUPPLEMENTAL INFO FROM ACN 98894: I WAS WORKING APPROX 10-12 ACFT AS A COMBINED APCH/DEP CTLR. CORP JET Y DEPARTED RWY 35 CLBING TO 4000' ON AN ASSIGNED HDG OF 040 DEGS; APPROX 1 MIN BEHIND SMA X. SMA X HAD LEVELED AT 4000'. ACFT Y WAS APCHING ACFT X AT 7 O'CLOCK POS AND ROUGHLY 1 MI DISTANCE WHEN HE CALLED ME; '...CLBING OUT OF 3500 FOR 4000'.' ON INITIAL CONTACT I SAID; 'N...; RADAR CONTACT; TURN LEFT HDG 360 DEGS.' I DID NOT ISSUE TFC TO CORP Y OR TO SMA X. IFR SEP HAD ALREADY BEEN LOST BY THE TIME CORP Y HAD MADE INITIAL CONTACT WITH ME. I ISSUED THE NBOUND TURN AS AN AVOIDANCE VECTOR BECAUSE THE TARGETS APPEARED LIKELY TO MERGE WITH BOTH ACFT RPTED AT THE SAME ALT. LCL CTLRS (A SUPVR TRNING ANOTHER SUPVR) DID NOT ENSURE INITIAL SEP OF IFR DEPS.

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.