11 fatalities

Maritime Patrol Flight Ends in Fatal Crash Off Labuan (VP254)

South China Sea, WorldFlight

On December 9, 1958, an Avro 696 Shackleton (registration VP254) operated by Royal Air Force - RAF was involved in an aviation accident near South China Sea, World in flight. 11 people were killed. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: It is believed the accident was caused by a wrong optical perception of the water surface on part of the flying crew as the water had a crystalline appearance. This summary draws on records from the Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A); 8 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

Sourcesthe Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A)Primary reportUpdated 2026-06-12Data APIEditorial standards

During a daytime maritime patrol over the South China Sea, an aircraft struck the water surface and crashed, killing all 11 occupants. Debris was later found about 450 km north of Labuan.

Background

On a daytime mission, an aircraft departed from Labuan Airport for a maritime patrol flight over the South China Sea. The crew consisted of ten members and one police officer, totaling 11 occupants.

Accident

While cruising at a low altitude over the sea, the airplane struck the water surface and crashed. Several hours later, debris from the aircraft and personal effects of the crew were observed floating on the water, approximately 450 km north of Labuan.

Investigation

Authorities investigated the accident and determined that all 11 occupants were killed. The investigation focused on the circumstances leading to the collision with the water.

Probable Cause

The official findings attributed the accident to a wrong optical perception of the water surface by the flying crew, as the water had a crystalline appearance. This led to a wrong perception of the situation and poor judgment of the distance between the airplane and the water surface. It was reported that the captain had not conducted any low-altitude mission for an extended period. Additionally, the copilot lacked experience on this type of aircraft, having just been appointed to the Shackleton from the Short Sunderland.