POTENTIAL CONFLICT. CLRNC INTERP PROB. TCASII SAVES THE DAY AGAIN!!
Synopsis
POTENTIAL CONFLICT. CLRNC INTERP PROB. TCASII SAVES THE DAY AGAIN!!
Narrative
CRUISING AT FL330 WE RECEIVED CLRNC 'EXPECT 7500 METERS OVER SL NDB; CALL READY FOR DSCNT' OR 'EXPECT 7500 METERS OR SL NDB; CALL DSNDING.' THE EXACT WORDING IS HAZEY. HOWEVER; AT THE TIME; I FIRMLY BELIEVED WE WERE CLRED TO DSND AND I STARTED DOWN. AT APPROX 32300 FT TCASII SHOWED TFC OPPOSITE AND AT FL310. TCASII SAID 'TFC; TFC' AND AT THE SAME TIME WE CHOSE TO RETURN TO FL330 AND ATC RECONFIRMED THAT WE SHOULD RETURN AND MAINTAIN FL330. SHORTLY THEREAFTER WE WERE CLRED DOWN AND HANDED OFF TO THE NEXT CTLR. SEPARATION APPEARED TO BE NO LESS THAN 1000 FT VERTLY AND APPROX 4-5 MI HORIZLY. ALL 3 CREWMEMBERS WERE EXPERIENCED ON THIS SECTION OF FLT AND WERE SURPRISED AND CONFUSED THAT SOMEHOW WE HAD POSSIBLY MISUNDERSTOOD OUR CLRNC. ATC WAS NOT CONCERNED ABOUT THE DSCNT BUT MERELY ADVISED US TO MAINTAIN FL330. CTLRS IN THIS AREA CAN SOMETIMES BE HARD TO UNDERSTAND AND CLRNCS ARE NOT ALWAYS; 'CLR AND CONCISE;' HOWEVER A REPEAT WILL OFTEN CLARIFY THINGS. SO; DID WE MISUNDERSTAND THE CLRNC OR WAS IT A POOR OR IMPROPER CLRNC? I AM DISTRESSED WITH THE THOUGHT THAT PERHAPS I DID NOT FOLLOW THE CLRNC OR THAT I DID NOT CLARIFY A POSSIBLY UNCLR CLRNC. ONE MUST BE CERTAIN OF THE CLRNC. A CONTRIBUTING FACTOR WAS THAT WE WERE WITHIN APPROX 30 MI OF THE NDB AND; THAT TO CROSS IT AT THE EXPECTED ALT; WE WOULD HAVE HAD TO DSND IMMEDIATELY.
More incidents for this aircraft family →
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.