FE RPT REGARDING ALTDEV WHEN CAPT DSNDS WITHOUT CLRNC AND TCASII RA RESULTS.

Date: 1996-05 · Aircraft: B727 Undifferentiated or Other Model

Anomalies: deviation-altitude-excursion-from-assigned-altitude|deviation-discrepancy-procedural-clearance|other-unspecified

Synopsis

FE RPT REGARDING ALTDEV WHEN CAPT DSNDS WITHOUT CLRNC AND TCASII RA RESULTS.

Narrative

WE WERE OPERATING FLT FROM NAS TO LGA. THIS CREW HAD BEEN TOGETHER MOST OF THE MONTH. THE CAPT AND FO WERE NOT COMMUNICATING VERY WELL. OUR FLT WAS AT FL330 WITH A CLB TO FL370 AT ILM. WE WERE CRUISING AT FL330 VFR WITH LIGHT CONTINUOUS CHOP. LIGHT CONTINUOUS WAS RPTED FROM FL280 THROUGH FL390. THE CAPT WENT BACK TO USE THE RESTROOM. WHILE HE WAS OUT OF COCKPIT ZJX ASKED US TO CLB TO FL370 OR SLOW TO MACH .74. AFTER CHKING THE BUFFET CHARTS I DECIDED WE WERE LEGAL AND SAFE TO CLB TO FL370. A SBOUND MD80 FLT HAD RPTED A THIN BAND OF MODERATE TURB AT FL350 AHEAD. WE STARTED OUR CLB TO FL370 WHEN CLRED BY ATC. THE CAPT REENTERED THE COCKPIT AS WE WERE CLBING THROUGH FL350. HE INQUIRED AS TO WHY WE WERE CLBING. WE STATED OUR 2 OPTIONS. WHEN HE GOT IN HIS SEAT; HE DISCONNECTED THE AUTOPLT AND CLOSED THE THROTTLES AND PUSHED THE NOSE OVER. WE WERE AROUND FL355. THE FO IMMEDIATELY CALLED ATC AND STATED THE CAPT'S DESIRE TO DSND. ATC SAID 'FL330 IS NOT AVAILABLE.' THE CAPT CONTINUED HIS DSCNT MANEUVER. THE FO AGAIN STATED 'THE CAPT WANTS TO DSND TO FL330 DUE TO BUMPS.' THE RESPONSE WAS THE SAME. AT THIS TIME WE RECEIVED A TA ON THE TCASII SBOUND TFC AT FL350. WE CONTINUED DSNDING. THE FO SAID TO CAPT WE DID NOT HAVE CLRNC. ZJX FINALLY SAID 'MAINTAIN FL330; TURN L TO 340 DEGS; MAINTAIN MACH .74.' WE WERE APPROX AT FL340 WHEN WE RECEIVED CLRNC. AFTER SEVERAL MINS ZJX TURNED US OVER TO ZDC. THE PROB OBVIOUSLY STARTS WITH THE CAPT'S DECISION TO DSND WITHOUT CLRNC. I FEEL THAT THE PROB WAS PERPETUATED BY THE FACT THAT THE CAPT AND FO WERE NOT DISPLAYING GOOD CRM WITH EACH OTHER. THE CAPT WANTED TO MAKE THE DECISION AND THAT WAS FINAL. SUPPLEMENTAL INFO FROM ACN 335871: I BELIEVE THAT THIS INCIDENT CAN BE PARTIALLY BLAMED ON TENSION BTWN THE CREW MEMBERS. THE CAPT CAME FROM ANOTHER AIRLINE; I DID NOT. THE CAPT HAS HIS OWN TECHNIQUES; I CHOOSE TO FOLLOW THE AIRLINE'S OPERATING MANUAL. THIS TENSION HAD BEEN AT A HIGH LEVEL THE ENTIRE MONTH. I BELIEVE THAT THE CAPT'S DECISION TO DSND TO FL330 WAS PARTIALLY JUST TO OVERRIDE MY ACCEPTANCE OF FL370.

More incidents for this aircraft family →

Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.