AN ACR FLC WRONGLY TAXIED INTO POS ON THE RWY AT CHARLES DE GAULLE INTL ARPT IN PARIS; FRANCE. THE CREW THOUGHT THAT THEY RECEIVED A CLRNC TO LINE UP AND WAIT AFTER THE 'DEPARTING' ACFT. THE CTLR INTERVENED AND STATED THAT THEY WERE CLRED TO LINE UP AND WAIT AFTER THE 'LNDG' ACFT. THE FINAL APCH AREA HAD BEEN CHKED PRIOR TO TAXIING ONTO THE RWY AND THE FLC SAW NO OTHER ACFT; SO THERE WAS NO CONFLICT.
Synopsis
AN ACR FLC WRONGLY TAXIED INTO POS ON THE RWY AT CHARLES DE GAULLE INTL ARPT IN PARIS; FRANCE. THE CREW THOUGHT THAT THEY RECEIVED A CLRNC TO LINE UP AND WAIT AFTER THE 'DEPARTING' ACFT. THE CTLR INTERVENED AND STATED THAT THEY WERE CLRED TO LINE UP AND WAIT AFTER THE 'LNDG' ACFT. THE FINAL APCH AREA HAD BEEN CHKED PRIOR TO TAXIING ONTO THE RWY AND THE FLC SAW NO OTHER ACFT; SO THERE WAS NO CONFLICT.
Narrative
WE WERE NEXT IN LINE FOR TKOF ON RWY 27 IN PARIS. ALL 3 CREW MEMBERS UNDERSTOOD TWR'S CLRNC AS 'AFTER DEPARTING ACFT CLRED TO LINE UP AND WAIT.' A PLANE JUST TOOK OFF AND WE TAXIED INTO POS AND HOLD. THE TWR THEN SAID THE CLRNC WAS 'AFTER LNDG ACFT CLRED TO LINE UP AND WAIT.' (ALL QUOTES ARE APPROX.) MYSELF AND FO CHKED FINAL PRIOR TO TAXIING ONTO RWY AND SAW NO ACFT. THE LNDG ACFT MUST HAVE BEEN SEVERAL MI OUT SINCE THE VISIBILITY WAS EXCELLENT. THE SITS LEADING TO THE EVENT WERE THE CTLR'S FRENCH ACCENT; THE HIGH NOISE LEVELS IN THE B727; AND THE USE OF 'FOLLOWING' TYPE OF CLRNCS. THEY SHOULD USE THE UNITED STATE'S PROCS OF GIVING POS AND HOLD CLRNCS ONLY AFTER THE LNDG ACFT HAS TOUCHED DOWN. THE CREW WAS NOT RUSHED AND EXPERIENCED IN EUROPEAN PROCS; AND THOSE AT CDG. WE MUST LISTEN VERY CAREFULLY TO THE FRENCH CTLRS AND NOT ANTICIPATE WHAT THEY SAY. CALLBACK CONVERSATION WITH RPTR REVEALED THE FOLLOWING INFO: AFTER HAVING SPENT MANY YRS OPERATING IN AND OUT OF PARIS; THIS RPTR (CAPT) FEELS THAT HE IS VERY CLR ABOUT THE INTENTION OF CERTAIN PHRASES OR CLRNCS RECEIVED FROM THE CTLRS; BUT THAT HE STILL MANAGED TO GET CAUGHT ON THIS ONE BECAUSE OF THE CTLR'S STRONG ACCENT COMBINED WITH THE NOISE LEVELS IN THE B727 COCKPIT. NO ONE IN THE CREW PERCEIVED THAT THERE MIGHT BE A PROB UNTIL THE CTLR CORRECTED THEM. RPTR ALSO WAS MISLED BY WHAT HE TERMS AN 'ASSUMPTION' ON HIS PART THAT THE ACFT THAT HAD JUST DEPARTED WAS THE ACFT THAT THEY WERE TO FOLLOW BECAUSE NO ONE ELSE WAS IN SIGHT WHEN THEY TAXIED ONTO THE RWY. TRAINING WAS NOT A FACTOR IN THIS INSTANCE; BUT RPTR STATES THAT HIS COMPANY DOES NOT RTE CHK FOREIGN OPS AND HE FEELS THAT AS A RESULT; THEY ARE OVERLOOKING A TREMENDOUS SOURCE OF INFO THAT CAN AND SHOULD BE USED FOR CREW FAMILIARIZATION -- SPECIFICALLY; IN BRIEFING FLCS THAT ARE NEW TO CERTAIN FOREIGN OPS. HE BELIEVES THAT THE LINE OP IS NOT THE PLACE TO JUST BE GETTING ACQUAINTED WITH FOREIGN USE OF CLRNCS; SINCE; EVEN IN THIS INSTANCE (WITH AN EXPERIENCED AND KNOWLEDGEABLE CREW); IT WAS STILL NOT POSSIBLE TO GET IT RIGHT. SUPPLEMENTAL INFO FROM ACN 340859: I CHKED FINAL AND I DID NOT SEE AN ACFT OR ACFT LIGHTS. THE TWR THEN CLRED US FOR AN IMMEDIATE TKOF. THERE WAS NO DANGER AND THE LNDG ACFT DID NOT HAVE TO DO A GAR. THE FRENCH SPEAK FRENCH TO THE FRENCH CREWS AND ENGLISH TO NON FRENCH CREWS. THEY DO NOT USE STANDARD INTL CLRNCS. THEY SAY 'LINE UP BEHIND' VERSUS 'CLRED INTO POS AND HOLD.'
More incidents for this aircraft family →
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.