A320 FLT CREW UNANTICIPATED ZLA CLRNC CHANGE TO SKEBR RNAV STAR CAUSES LATE RECOGNITION TO CORRECT FMS PROGRAMMING TO MEET AMENDED MISEN INTXN XING RESTR.
Synopsis
A320 FLT CREW UNANTICIPATED ZLA CLRNC CHANGE TO SKEBR RNAV STAR CAUSES LATE RECOGNITION TO CORRECT FMS PROGRAMMING TO MEET AMENDED MISEN INTXN XING RESTR.
Narrative
WHILE FLYING INBOUND ON THE 'SKEBR RNAV 2 ARR' I WAS HIGH AT THE XING RESTR AT THE MISEN ARR FIX. THE PROB WAS THAT IN THE FMGC ON THE AIRBUS; THE ENTIRE RNAV ARR IS BUILT IN THE BOX AS DEPICTED ON THE PLATE. THAT PLATE ACTUALLY SAYS TO CROSS MISEN AT OR ABOVE FL240. I BELIEVE THAT THE CTLR GAVE US MISEN AT FL240. THE COMPUTER WANTED TO CROSS 'AT OR ABOVE.' BY THE TIME I REALIZED THE ERROR; I HURRIED DOWN TO CROSS MISEN AT FL240. BOTTOM LINE IS THAT I WAS HIGHER THAN FL240 WHEN WE CROSSED. WHILE THIS WOULD BE CONSIDERED PLT ERROR; I BELIEVE THAT THERE ARE SOME PROBS AND/OR CONFUSION OFTEN ASSOCIATED WITH THESE RNAV ARRS. THEY WORK PRETTY WELL WHEN YOU CAN JUST FLY THEM AS THEY ARE DEPICTED (WHICH I BELIEVED WAS THE WHOLE POINT TO THEM). IN REAL LIFE; THEY DON'T USUALLY LEAVE YOU ON THEM. THE CTLRS CHANGE SOME PARTS OF THEM -- USUALLY ALTS -- TO FIT IN SOMEHOW WITH OTHER TFC. CLRING YOU FOR A 'PRE CANNED' ARR THEN LATER CHANGING PARTS OF IT; SEEMS TO ME TO BE SETTING YOU UP TO MISS SOMETHING. I THINK THAT WE SHOULD EITHER FLY THE ARRS AS DEPICTED OR GO BACK TO THE OLD ARRS WITHOUT ALL OF THE PREASSIGNED ALTS.
More incidents for this aircraft family →
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.