ZDV QUESTIONS A320 FLT CREW AFTER OBSERVING AN ALT 1000 FT BELOW A BLOCK ALT ASSIGNMENT DUE TO TURB. FLT CREW INSISTS THE LOWER ALT WAS PART OF BLOCK ALT ASSIGNMENT.
Synopsis
ZDV QUESTIONS A320 FLT CREW AFTER OBSERVING AN ALT 1000 FT BELOW A BLOCK ALT ASSIGNMENT DUE TO TURB. FLT CREW INSISTS THE LOWER ALT WAS PART OF BLOCK ALT ASSIGNMENT.
Narrative
WE WERE WBOUND ENRTE FROM JFK TO OAK. WE WERE ABOUT 1/2 WAY INTO THE FLT AND EXPERIENCING CONTINUOUS LIGHT TURB AT FL370. ALTHOUGH THIS WAS AN EBOUND ALT; IT WAS REQUESTED AND SUBSEQUENTLY APPROVED BY THE PREVIOUS ENRTE CTLR. IT WAS REQUESTED AFTER CONSIDERING THE ACFT PERFORMANCE CAPABILITY; AS DETERMINED BY THE FMS. EARLIER WHILE CRUISING AT FL350; WE ENCOUNTERED A SIMILAR CHOPPY RIDE. THE RIDE AT FL370 BECAME CHOPPY PRIMARILY DUE TO AN OVCST LAYER WHICH COINCIDED WITH OUR ALT. I AGAIN CHKED THE ACFT CAPABILITY; AND SAW THAT WE WERE STILL UNABLE FL390. WE REQUESTED A BLOCK FROM FL350-FL380. THE CTLR THEN ASSIGNED BLOCK FL350-FL390; AND EXPLAINED THAT SHE COULD NOT ASSIGN FL380. AS WE FLEW WBOUND; VARIOUS ALT CHANGES WERE MADE FOR PAX COMFORT/TURB AVOIDANCE. APPROX 120 NM E OF DEN; I DSNDED TO FL360 KEEPING US BELOW A LAYER. UPON REACHING LEVEL AT FL360; THE CTR CTLR REQUESTED US TO 'VERIFY ALT.' I RESPONDED LEVEL AT FL360. SHE THEN STATED THAT WE WERE ASSIGNED FL370-FL390. I CHALLENGED THE CTLR; AND ASSERTED THAT WE WERE ASSIGNED A BLOCK FROM FL350-FL390. SHE DISPUTED THIS; AT WHICH POINT WE REQUESTED A NEW BLOCK OF FL350-FL370. THIS WAS SUBSEQUENTLY ASSIGNED; AND WE CONTINUED AT FL360 UNTIL A CTLR CLOSER TO OAK ASSIGNED A DSCNT TO FL350. WHILE I MAINTAIN THAT WE WERE GRANTED A CLRNC FROM FL350 TO FL390; I CANNOT CONFIRM IT WITHOUT A REPLAY OF THE TAPE. IF THERE WAS A DEV FROM THE CLRNC; IT MAY HAVE BEEN A COMBINATION OF LATE HR ( DOMICILE TIME); DISTR (TURB); AND HEARBACK EXPECTATION. THE CTLR DID NOT HAVE ANY INPUT AFTER THE REVISED CLRNC WAS ISSUED; SO I BELIEVE THAT A TFC CONFLICT WAS NOT AN IMMEDIATE THREAT. IN THE FUTURE; I PLAN TO BE MORE VIGILANT WHEN REQUESTING BLOCK CRUISE ALTS; AS IT IS OUT OF THE NORM FROM ROUTINE FLT OPS.
More incidents for this aircraft family →
Source: NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System (public domain). Reports are voluntary submissions and are not verified by NASA.