No fatalities

Carburetor Heat Bracket Failure Leads to Forced Landing and Gear Collapse

Urbana, OH, United States

On June 20, 2009, a PIPER PA-24 operated by Marc S. Comegys was involved in an aviation accident near Urbana, OH. No fatalities were reported. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: A failure of the carburetor heat cable attach bracket which resulted in the inadvertent activation of carburetor heat and the subsequent loss of engine power during takeoff. This summary draws on records from NTSB; 12 related events involving the same aircraft type or operator are linked below.

SourcesNTSBPrimary reportUpdated 2026-08-03Data APIEditorial standards

Pilot encountered carburetor heat issues, then loss of engine power at 200 feet. Landing gear collapsed during field landing; left wing damaged. Post-accident inspection revealed fractured carburetor heat bracket.

Preflight and First Flight

During the engine run-up before the first flight of the day, the pilot noted no resistance on the control knob when checking the carburetor heat operation. The engine RPM returned to normal with a slightly sluggish response. The first flight proceeded without further issue.

Second Flight Incident

During the second flight's engine run-up, applying carburetor heat caused the RPM needle to wiggle down by 50 RPM before returning to the set value. The takeoff appeared normal until reaching about 200 feet above the runway, when the aircraft felt "soggy." The pilot raised the landing gear to reduce drag, but the engine still did not seem to be producing power. He then extended the landing gear and decided to land in a field off the end of the runway.

Landing and Damage

During the landing, the landing gear, which was not locked down, collapsed. The left wing contacted a runway end identifier light, resulting in substantial damage.

Post-Accident Inspection

Post-accident examination of the airplane and engine revealed that the carburetor heat bracket between the valve shaft and the cable was fractured and missing. The carburetor heat valve was found in the open position.

Contributing factors

Causes

Fuel control/carburetor — Failure

Other contributing factors

Contributed to outcomePilot

All Piper PA-24 accidents →

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 20 Jun 2009 PIPER PA-24 accident near Urbana, OH?

Pilot encountered carburetor heat issues, then loss of engine power at 200 feet. Landing gear collapsed during field landing; left wing damaged. Post-accident inspection revealed fractured carburetor heat bracket.

Were there any fatalities in the 20 Jun 2009 PIPER PA-24 accident?

No fatalities were recorded in this accident.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 20 Jun 2009 involved a PIPER PA-24, operated by Marc S. Comegys, at Urbana, OH.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

A failure of the carburetor heat cable attach bracket which resulted in the inadvertent activation of carburetor heat and the subsequent loss of engine power during takeoff. Contributing to the accident was the pilot's operation of the aircraft with a known deficiency.