No fatalities

27 Nov 2017: MOTLEY GARY W ZENITH CH750 CRUZER NO SERIES (N956GM) — Louviers, CO

Louviers, CO, United States

On 27 Nov 2017, a MOTLEY GARY W ZENITH CH750 CRUZER NO SERIES (registration N956GM) was involved in an aviation accident near Louviers, CO. No fatalities were reported. Investigators recorded the probable cause as: The ECU ran the engine too lean, resulting in excessive cylinder head temperatures, which unseated the head gasket, pressurized the coolant jacket, and evacuated engine coolant, leading to engine seizure. This summary draws on records from NTSB.

SourcesNTSBPrimary reportUpdated 1778583330Data APIEditorial standards

On November 27, 2017, the pilot of a Zenith CH750 Cruzer made a forced landing near Louviers, Colorado, after the engine lost power due to ECU-induced lean condition. The pilot was not injured; the aircraft sustained substantial damage.

Accident Summary

On November 27, 2017, at about 1520 mountain standard time, a Zenith CH750 Cruzer, registration N956GM, experienced a loss of engine power and was forced to land in an open field near Louviers, Colorado. The pilot, who was the sole occupant, was not injured. The aircraft, however, sustained substantial damage.

Flight Details

The flight was a personal flight conducted under 14 CFR Part 91. It originated from Rocky Mountain Metropolitan Airport (BJC) in Broomfield, Colorado, at approximately 1440. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and no flight plan was filed. The purpose of the flight was to evaluate engine performance after the pilot had installed a replacement Engine Control Unit (ECU) with updated programming.

Engine Failure

The pilot flew to his designated phase 1 flight area near Louviers and was conducting autopilot testing when the engine monitor alerted him to high engine coolant temperature. He reduced power and initiated a turn back toward the airport. Subsequently, engine RPM decreased and temperature continued to rise, while fuel and oil pressures remained within normal limits. Shortly thereafter, the engine seized and the propeller stopped rotating. The pilot attempted two engine restarts, including a complete reboot of the ECU, but was unsuccessful.

Forced Landing

With the engine inoperative, the pilot executed a forced landing in an open field. During the landing, the airplane struck an unseen barbed wire fence, which collapsed the nose landing gear and crushed the engine cowling. The right-wing strut was bent, and some wing skin damage occurred. Post-landing inspection revealed that the coolant expansion tank had overfilled due to overheating.

Post-Accident Examination

Upon later examination of the engine, the pilot found that the ECU had run the engine too lean, resulting in excessive cylinder head temperatures. This caused the head gasket to unseat, pressurizing the coolant jacket and evacuating engine coolant overboard. The pilot discovered coolant in three of the four cylinders and oil mixed in the coolant under the thermostat, which led to a rapid rise in coolant temperature and eventual engine stoppage.

Probable cause

The ECU ran the engine too lean, resulting in excessive cylinder head temperatures, which unseated the head gasket, pressurized the coolant jacket, and evacuated engine coolant, leading to engine seizure.

Contributing factors

Causes

Recip eng liquid cooling — Failure

Other contributing factors

Contributed to outcome