Fatal Beechcraft B55 Crash in Brazil Linked to Overweight and Imbalance

Casualties unknown • PORTO NACIONAL, TO, BR

A Beechcraft 95-B55 crashed shortly after takeoff in Porto Nacional, Brazil, resulting in six fatalities due to excessive weight and improper center of gravity.

What happened

On January 24, 2021, a 95-B5 and registration PT-LYG departed from the Associação Tocantinense de Aviação Aerodrome (SWEJ) in Porto Nacional, Brazil, bound for Goiânia. The aircraft was operating a private flight carrying the pilot and five passengers.

Shortly after takeoff, the aircraft experienced a loss of lift. Witnesses observed that during the takeoff roll, the auxiliary landing gear briefly left the runway and then made contact again, suggesting difficulty in rotating the aircraft. As the pilot began retracting the landing gear, the aircraft entered an abnormal pitch-up attitude. This sudden change in flight attitude led to a loss of control at a low altitude, causing the aircraft to strike the ground in a leveled attitude. The impact triggered a post-crash fire that consumed the entire fuselage, leaving only fragments of the engines, wings, and tail cone. All six occupants sustained fatal injuries.

The investigation

CENIPA investigators analyzed the wreckage, engine performance, and flight planning. While the engines and propellers appeared to be operating normally at the time of impact, the investigation focused on the aircraft's weight and balance.

By analyzing passenger weights, estimated luggage, and fuel levels, the investigation team determined that the aircraft was likely operating significantly above its maximum takeoff weight. Specifically, the aircraft was estimated to be approximately 300.75 kg over its maximum allowable weight. Furthermore, the distribution of the load placed the center of gravity (CG) beyond the rear limit established by the manufacturer, with calculations suggesting a displacement of at least 2 inches beyond the permitted range.

Findings

  • The aircraft was operating above its maximum takeoff weight.
  • The center of gravity was displaced beyond the manufacturer's rear limit due to improper weight distribution.
  • Inadequate flight planning regarding the loading of passengers and luggage contributed to the weight and balance error.
  • The decision to continue the flight after the aircraft failed to rotate as expected during the takeoff run contributed to the loss of control.

Probable cause

The accident was caused by the aircraft operating in an overweight condition and with a center of gravity beyond the rear limit, which induced an uncontrollable pitch-up attitude during landing gear retraction.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2021-01-24 aircraft accident near PORTO NACIONAL, TO, BR?

A Beechcraft 95-B55 crashed shortly after takeoff in Porto Nacional, Brazil, resulting in six fatalities due to excessive weight and improper center of gravity.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2021-01-24 involved a aircraft, registration PTLYG, at PORTO NACIONAL, TO, BR.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The accident was caused by the aircraft operating in an overweight condition and with a center of gravity beyond the rear limit, which induced an uncontrollable pitch-up attitude during landing gear retraction.

Loading the flight search…