Winch Operator Error Leads to Hard Landing of Glider in Hokkaido

Casualties unknown • Shinshinotsu Gliding Field, Shinshinotsu-Mura, Ishikari-Gun, Hokkaido, JP

A winch-launched glider sustained damage and two serious injuries after the operator prematurely stopped the winch, causing the towline to disengage.

What happened

On November 3, 2021, an Alexander Schleicher ASK13 glider, registration JA100K, was undergoing a training flight at the Shinshinotsu Gliding Field in Hokkaido, Japan. The flight was being conducted via a winch launch with a student pilot in the front seat and an instructor in the rear.

Prior to the launch, the crew experienced significant difficulty communicating with the winch operator due to poor radio signal quality. To bypass this, the launch director at the command post acted as a relay between the glider and the winch. During the takeoff roll, the launch director noticed the acceleration seemed slower than usual and repeated the launch command multiple times.

As the glider climbed, the winch operator—believing the repeated signals and the lack of visible movement indicated a severed towline—decided to stop the winch operation. The operator did not communicate this stoppage to the crew. Without the forward tension of the winch, the towline eventually disengaged from the glider's hook. The crew heard a distinct "clack" sound and realized the connection was lost. The instructor attempted to recover the aircraft by lowering the nose, but the glider's airspeed dropped well below stall speed. The aircraft subsequently performed a hard landing in a grass area, resulting in two serious injuries and damage to the aircraft's wing rib and control surfaces.

The investigation

The Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB) examined the radio communication logs, the winch operation procedures, and video footage recorded by a head-mounted camera worn by the trainee. The investigation focused on the sequence of events leading to the towline disengagement and the decision-making process of the ground crew. Investigators also reviewed the Association's established winch launching protocols and the physical condition of the aircraft and winch equipment following the impact.

Probable cause

The accident was caused by the winch operator's decision to stop the winch operation under the mistaken belief that the towline had broken. Because the crew was not notified of the stoppage, the glider continued its climb without tension, leading to the towline disengaging and the aircraft falling below stall speed.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2021-11-03 Alexander Schleicher ASK13 (Glider, Two-Seater) accident near Shinshinotsu Gliding Field, Shinshinotsu-Mura, Ishikari-Gun, Hokkaido, JP?

A winch-launched glider sustained damage and two serious injuries after the operator prematurely stopped the winch, causing the towline to disengage.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2021-11-03 involved a Alexander Schleicher ASK13 (Glider, Two-Seater), registration JA100K, operated by Sapporo Aviation Association, at Shinshinotsu Gliding Field, Shinshinotsu-Mura, Ishikari-Gun, Hokkaido, JP.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The accident was caused by the winch operator's decision to stop the winch operation under the mistaken belief that the towline had broken. Because the crew was not notified of the stoppage, the glider continued its climb without tension, leading to the towline disengaging and the aircraft falling below stall speed.

Investigation report by the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB). Original record: https://jtsb.mlit.go.jp/eng-air_report/JA100K.pdf. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB) - Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism.

Loading the flight search…