Control confusion during landing approach leads to aircraft damage at Saltby Airfield

Casualties unknown • Saltby Airfield, Lincolnshire, GB

A training flight in a Hoffmann H 36 Dimima resulted in a hard landing and engine damage due to pilot error during turbulent conditions.

What happened

On 24 April 2015, a Hoffmann H 36 Dimona, registration G-BNUX, was conducting training circuits at Saltby Airfield in Lincolnshire. During the third circuit of the flight, the pilot encountered increasing turbulence and crosswinds, with winds measured from 210-220 degrees at 15-20 knots. After the aircraft ballooned at 20 feet, the pilot initiated a go-around.

On the subsequent approach, the level of turbulence intensified. The pilot attempted to manage the aircraft by using his left hand on the control column and his right hand on the spoiler/brake lever, a technique contrary to his previous flying experience. As the aircraft reached approximately 40 feet, strong buffeting occurred. During this period, the pilot experienced significant confusion, mistakenly treating the spoiler lever as the control column and the control column as the spoiler lever. Consequently, the aircraft entered a rapid descent before bouncing back into the air. The pilot failed to apply full throttle to abort the landing, leading to a hard impact with the ground. The aircraft remained in a level attitude during the impact, resulting in damage to the propeller and engine.

The investigation

The investigation was based on the aircraft accident report submitted by the pilot. Investigators examined the flight conditions, the pilot's experience, and the sequence of control inputs during the final approach. The pilot's recent flying experience was noted as being low, with only 6 hours flown in the previous 90 days and 3 hours in the previous 28 days. The investigation focused on the pilot's physical handling of the controls during the period of high turbulence.

Probable cause

The pilot's confusion regarding the aircraft's control inputs—specifically misidentifying the spoiler lever and control column—during heavy turbulence led to an uncontrolled descent and a hard landing.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2015-04-24 Hoffmann H 36 Dimona accident near Saltby Airfield, Lincolnshire, GB?

A training flight in a Hoffmann H 36 Dimima resulted in a hard landing and engine damage due to pilot error during turbulent conditions.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2015-04-24 involved a Hoffmann H 36 Dimona, registration G-BNUX, at Saltby Airfield, Lincolnshire, GB.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The pilot's confusion regarding the aircraft's control inputs—specifically misidentifying the spoiler lever and control column—during heavy turbulence led to an uncontrolled descent and a hard landing.

Loading the flight search…