Amphibious Aircraft Nose Breaks Up During Water Landing

Casualties unknown • Accident involving the aircraft N-84142 on the lake Hultebräan, SE

A LAKE 250 aircraft sustained substantial damage and two serious injuries after the nose section broke up during a landing on Hultebräan lake.

What happened

On 11 August 2012, a LAKE 250 aircraft, registration N-84142, was performing a local pleasure flight on Hultebräan lake in Kalmar County. During the landing sequence, the aircraft made contact with the water surface. While the pilot initially perceived a normal touchdown, a witness and the passenger reported that the aircraft bounced after an initial contact, briefly leaving the water before a second, more severe impact occurred.

Upon the second contact, the aircraft's nose was positioned too low, preventing the fuselage's 'step' from breaking the water surface. This caused water to be drawn upward along the fuselage, creating intense drag. The high-mounted engine, weighing approximately 350 kg, created a significant forward pitching moment as resistance increased. This momentum caused the forebody of the aircraft to break apart and the plane to nose over, eventually floating upside down. Both the pilot and the passenger sustained serious injuries, including fractures, but were rescued by bystanders in nearby boats.

The investigation

The Swedish Accident Investigation Authority (SHK) examined the wreckage and interviewed witnesses and the occupants. The investigation focused on the hydrodynamic characteristics of the aircraft during water contact. Investigators analyzed the structural failure of the nose section, noting that the underside panels showed indentations from water pressure while the topside showed compression folding. The investigation also reviewed the engine's position and mass relative to the aircraft's center of gravity and the functionality of the aircraft's 'step' design.

Probable cause

The accident was caused by the aircraft's fuselage design, where even minor deviations from the ideal landing angle risk the nose being sucked into the water, compounded by the high-mounted engine's mass contributing to a forward tip as water resistance increased.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2012-08-11 aircraft accident near Accident involving the aircraft N-84142 on the lake Hultebräan, SE?

A LAKE 250 aircraft sustained substantial damage and two serious injuries after the nose section broke up during a landing on Hultebräan lake.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2012-08-11 involved a aircraft, registration N-84142, at Accident involving the aircraft N-84142 on the lake Hultebräan, SE.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The accident was caused by the aircraft's fuselage design, where even minor deviations from the ideal landing angle risk the nose being sucked into the water, compounded by the high-mounted engine's mass contributing to a forward tip as water resistance increased.

Loading the flight search…