Tow rope detachment during glider demonstration flight near Komatsu Airport

Casualties unknown • At An altitude of approx. 150 m over vicinity of KOMATSU Airport, ISHIKAWA Prefecture, JP

A tow rope connecting a Diamond HK36TTC Super Dimona and an Alexander Schleicher ASK21 fractured and detached during a demonstration flight, resulting in the rope dropping onto airport grounds.

What happened

On September 16, 2019, at approximately 12:03 JST, a demonstration flight near Komatsu Airport resulted in the unintentional release of a tow rope. The operation involved a Diamond Aircraft HK36TTC Super Dimona, registered JA01KY, acting as the tow plane, and an Alexander Schleicher ASK21, registered JA2471, acting as the towed glider. Both aircraft were operated by the Japan Student Aviation League.

The flight sequence began with a takeoff from Fukui Airport. After completing initial demonstration patterns at an altitude of approximately 500 to 600 feet, the aircraft entered a left-hand circling maneuver for a third round. During this turn, the pilot of the tow plane felt a sudden impact and realized the tow rope had fractured. The glider pilot, upon feeling the separation, attempted to detach the remaining rope but followed the instructions of the second crew member to avoid ground damage. The glider landed safely on a taxiway, while the tow plane returned to Fukuit Airport. A 61-meter section of the 7mm diameter tow rope was subsequently recovered from a grassy area near the airport's runway 24 threshold.

The investigation

The JTSB investigation focused on the physical condition of the tow rope and the mechanical integrity of the connection points. Investigators examined the fractured ends of the rope, specifically the "stop egg" (an egg-shaped fitting on the tow plane side) and the "end piece" (the attachment on the glider side).

Technical analysis revealed that the rope used was an aftermarket polyester rope rather than the manufacturer's original specification. The investigation also scrutinized the knotting methods used at both ends of the rope. Furthermore, the JTSB reviewed the maintenance records and the adequacy of the flight manual instructions regarding tow rope inspections and installation procedures.

Probable cause

The incident was caused by the simultaneous fracture of the tow rope at the tow plane's stop egg and the untying of the knot at the glider's end piece. This was driven by the rope's reduced strength due to improper knotting and the use of a rope that had not been verified for strength under actual knotted conditions.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2019-09-16 Diamond Aircraft HK36TTC Super Dimona/Alexander Schleicher ASK21 accident near At An altitude of approx. 150 m over vicinity of KOMATSU Airport, ISHIKAWA Prefecture, JP?

A tow rope connecting a Diamond HK36TTC Super Dimona and an Alexander Schleicher ASK21 fractured and detached during a demonstration flight, resulting in the rope dropping onto airport grounds.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2019-09-16 involved a Diamond Aircraft HK36TTC Super Dimona/Alexander Schleicher ASK21, registration JA01KY/JA2471, operated by The public foundation of Japan Student Aviation League, at At An altitude of approx. 150 m over vicinity of KOMATSU Airport, ISHIKAWA Prefecture, JP.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The incident was caused by the simultaneous fracture of the tow rope at the tow plane's stop egg and the untying of the knot at the glider's end piece. This was driven by the rope's reduced strength due to improper knotting and the use of a rope that had not been verified for strength under actual knotted conditions.

Investigation report by the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB). Original record: https://jtsb.mlit.go.jp/eng-air_report/JA01KY_JA2471.pdf. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the Japan Transport Safety Board (JTSB) - Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism.

Loading the flight search…