Near Mid-Air Collision in Malmö FIR Due to Controller Workload

Casualties unknown • Air Traffic Incident between the Aircrafts F-GBYC from Air France of type B737 and G-BNLK from British Airways of type B747 in the Airspace West of Kolja, SE

Two commercial airliners narrowly avoided a collision in Swedish airspace after an air traffic controller, managing a high workload and training a student, cleared a descending aircraft into the path of an oncoming flight.

What happened

On April 17, 1998, a Boeing 737-20 and a Boeing 747-400 experienced a near mid-air collision in the airspace west of the KOLJA intersection within the Malmö FIR. The Air France flight, operating as F-GBYC, was cruising at 35,000 feet when the air traffic controller at position R 7 decided to descend the aircraft to 31,000 feet. This maneuver was intended to allow a faster-moving aircraft to overtake without delay.

However, the controller failed to identify that a British Airways flight, G-BNLK, was traveling on an intersecting course at 33,000 feet. During the descent, the crew of F-GBYC observed the oncoming heavy jet and performed evasive maneuvers to the right. The aircraft passed each other with a lateral separation of less than 1 nautical mile and a vertical separation of only approximately 300 feet. The crew of G-BNLK also performed evasive action and subsequently received a TCAS warning.

The investigation

An investigation by the Swedish Board of Accident Investigation (SHK) focused on the air traffic control environment at the time of the incident. The controller at position R 7 was simultaneously instructing a student, which increased the complexity of the task. At the time of the event, the controller was managing a high volume of traffic following a sudden influx of flight strips.

Investigators also examined the possibility of a radar mosaic effect, where the intersection of two radar stations can cause an aircraft echo to disappear temporarily. While the controller noted that this might have obscured the incoming flight during the conflict search, the investigation primarily focused on the operational pressures present in the sector.

Probable cause

The near collision was primarily caused by the air traffic controller's heavy workload and the simultaneous responsibility of training a student, which prevented an effective conflict search. The lack of an administrative assistant (D-position) during high traffic density further contributed to the oversight.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 1998-04-17 aircraft accident near Air Traffic Incident between the Aircrafts F-GBYC from Air France of type B737 and G-BNLK from British Airways of type B747 in the Airspace West of Kolja, SE?

Two commercial airliners narrowly avoided a collision in Swedish airspace after an air traffic controller, managing a high workload and training a student, cleared a descending aircraft into the path of an oncoming flight.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 1998-04-17 involved a aircraft, registration F-GBYC, at Air Traffic Incident between the Aircrafts F-GBYC from Air France of type B737 and G-BNLK from British Airways of type B747 in the Airspace West of Kolja, SE.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The near collision was primarily caused by the air traffic controller's heavy workload and the simultaneous responsibility of training a student, which prevented an effective conflict search. The lack of an administrative assistant (D-position) during high traffic density further contributed to the oversight.

Loading the flight search…