Engine failure and hard landing during ULM training flight

Casualties unknown • Aérodrome de Merville Calonne, FR

A Rans Coyote S6 ultralight experienced two engine failures during a training circuit, resulting in a hard landing and significant aircraft damage.

What happened

On July 25, 2012, a Rans Coyote S6 ultralight, identified as 59-DCJ, was performing a training flight at the Merville Calost aerodrome. The flight, which involved an instructor and a student, began with a takeoff from an unpaved runway for the purpose of circuit training. Shortly after the initial climb reached approximately 300 feet, the engine suddenly stopped. The instructor took control of the aircraft to perform an emergency landing in a nearby field. During this maneuver, the student managed to restart the engine, allowing the instructor to continue the flight at a low altitude to complete the circuit and return to the runway. After handing control back to the student, the engine failed a second time during the final approach. Believing there was insufficient altitude to attempt another restart but enough to reach the runway, the instructor allowed the student to continue the landing. The student, experiencing significant stress, initiated the flare too high. This resulted in a hard landing where the aircraft struck the runway and bounced several times, causing the landing gear to break and the aircraft to come to a halt on the runway.

The investigation

The investigation focused on the cause of the dual engine failures and the circumstances leading to the landing error. Investigators examined the fuel system of the BMW R1100 engine, noting that the student, who is also an aircraft mechanic, identified the system as being susceptible to "vapor lock." This phenomenon occurs when fuel boils in the fuel lines due to high temperatures. On the day of the accident, the aircraft had remained stationary with the engine idling for approximately 15 minutes due to heavy airfield traffic. The ambient temperature was 27°C, creating conditions highly conducive to fuel vaporization. The investigation also reviewed the crew's decision-making process during the second engine failure and the subsequent landing execution.

Probable cause

The primary cause of the accident was an incorrect assessment of altitude during the flare. Contributing factors included the instructor's overconfidence in the student pilot, the stress caused by the emergency engine failure, and the occurrence of vapor lock in the fuel system.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2012-07-25 aircraft accident near Aérodrome de Merville Calonne, FR?

A Rans Coyote S6 ultralight experienced two engine failures during a training circuit, resulting in a hard landing and significant aircraft damage.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2012-07-25 involved a aircraft, registration 59-DCJ, at Aérodrome de Merville Calonne, FR.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The primary cause of the accident was an incorrect assessment of altitude during the flare. Contributing factors included the instructor's overconfidence in the student pilot, the stress caused by the emergency engine failure, and the occurrence of vapor lock in the fuel system.

Loading the flight search…