Canadair CL 415 winglet damaged during aerial firefighting operation

Casualties unknown • Comune di Pietra Ligure, IT

A Canadair CL 415 aircraft lost a significant portion of its left winglet after striking an unmarked power line cable during a forest fire suppression mission in Italy.

What happened

On January 1, 2002, a Canadair CL 415, registration I-DPCN, was engaged in aerial firefighting operations to suppress a forest fire in a valley east of Pietra Ligure, Italy. During the mission, the crew had completed four successful water drops. However, following feedback from ground personnel that wind conditions were drifting the water away from the fire line, the crew adjusted their flight path closer to an electrical power line installation.

During the fifth pass, as the aircraft began a turning maneuver following the water release, the left wingtip struck an unmarked ground wire belonging to the southernmost line of the power installation. The impact caused approximately three-quarters of the left winglet to be severed. The detached structural component fell into a private garden, though no injuries or ground damage were reported. The crew immediately ceased firefighting operations, verified the aircraft's controllability, and returned to Rome Ciampino Airport, landing without further incident.

The investigation

The ANSV investigation examined the aircraft's structural integrity, the flight dynamics, and the environmental conditions at the time of the event. Technical analysis of the winglet fracture revealed that the impact occurred at a low speed (approximately 120 knots). The ground wire acted as a buffer, stretching progressively and creating a tearing action rather than a clean cut, which eventually lacerated the winglet structure.

Investigators also reviewed flight footage from an amateur video, which helped reconstruct the flight path and altitude (approximately 150 feet). The investigation noted that while the northernmost line of the power installation featured high-visibility marker spheres, the southern line was unmarked. Furthermore, the investigation considered the impact of environmental factors, including heavy smoke from the fire and intense sunlight, which created challenging visual conditions for the crew.

Probable cause

The primary cause of the event was a collision with power lines resulting from an inadequate assessment of the safety distance from the cables. Contributing factors included parallax errors caused by the pilot's seated position, the lack of adequate marking on the southern power line, the dark coloring of the support pylons which made them difficult to distinguish from vegetation, and challenging lighting conditions caused by smoke and direct sunlight.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the null CL415, accident near Comune di Pietra Ligure, IT?

A Canadair CL 415 aircraft lost a significant portion of its left winglet after striking an unmarked power line cable during a forest fire suppression mission in Italy.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on null involved a CL415,, registration I-DPCN, at Comune di Pietra Ligure, IT.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The primary cause of the event was a collision with power lines resulting from an inadequate assessment of the safety distance from the cables. Contributing factors included parallax errors caused by the pilot's seated position, the lack of adequate marking on the southern power line, the dark coloring of the support…

Investigation report by the Italian National Flight Safety Agency (ANSV). Original record: https://ansv.it/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/I-DPCN.pdf. This page is a structured re-presentation; facts and quotes are in the Agenzia Nazionale per la Sicurezza del Volo (ANSV), Italy.

Loading the flight search…