Hot Air Balloon Collision Causes Unreliable Speed Condition in Airbus A319

Casualties unknown • RIO DE JANEIRO, RJ, BR

An Airbus A319 flying near Rio de Janeiro experienced flight automation degradation after colliding with a hot air balloon banner, forcing the crew to manage an unreliable airspeed indication.

What happened

On June 17, 2011, an Airbus A319-132, registration PT-MZC, operated by TAM Linhas Aéreas, was climbing through FL120 in the Rio de Janeiro terminal area during a flight from Santos Dumont (SBRJ) to Confins (SBCF). During the climb, the crew was alerted by Air Traffic Control to the presence of hot air balloons in the vicinity. Shortly thereafter, the aircraft collided with a plastic banner attached to a hot air balloon.

The impact caused the obstruction of all three Pitot tubes and the Total Air Temperature (TAT) sensor with plastic debris. This led to a rapid degradation of the aircraft's automated flight systems, triggering several ECAM warnings, including NAV ADR DISAGREE, F/CTL ALTN LAW, and AUTO FLT AP/A-THR OFF. The crew was forced to manage an unreliable airspeed condition for the remainder of the flight. Despite the loss of automation and discrepancies in airspeed indications between the primary flight displays, the crew successfully landed the aircraft at SBCF. There were no fatalities and no injuries among the 95 passengers and 6 crew members, though the aircraft sustained light damage.

The investigation

CENIPA's investigation focused on the impact of the debris on the aircraft's sensors and the crew's subsequent management of the emergency. Investigators found that the plastic residue from the balloon banner physically blocked the critical flight data sensors. The analysis also examined the crew's cockpit coordination and the airline's training programs. It was noted that during the emergency, the crew's management of tasks was inadequate, specifically regarding the use of the Quick Reference Handbook (QRH) and task-sharing. Furthermore, the investigation looked into the airline's training curriculum regarding unreliable airspeed procedures and the regulatory environment surrounding the release of uncontrolled balloons in Brazilian airspace.

Probable cause

The primary cause of the incident was the collision with a hot air balloon banner, which obstructed the Pitot tubes and TAT sensor, leading to the loss of automated flight systems and unreliable airspeed indications. Contributing factors included inadequate cockpit coordination and improper use of the QRH during the emergency, as well as training programs that did not fully cover all phases of flight for unreliable speed procedures.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2011-06-17 aircraft accident near RIO DE JANEIRO, RJ, BR?

An Airbus A319 flying near Rio de Janeiro experienced flight automation degradation after colliding with a hot air balloon banner, forcing the crew to manage an unreliable airspeed indication.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2011-06-17 involved a aircraft, registration PTMZC, at RIO DE JANEIRO, RJ, BR.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The primary cause of the incident was the collision with a hot air balloon banner, which obstructed the Pitot tubes and TAT sensor, leading to the loss of automated flight systems and unreliable airspeed indications. Contributing factors included inadequate cockpit coordination and improper use of the QRH during the…

Loading the flight search…