Main parachute deployment causes structural damage to Pilatus Porter

Casualties unknown • Conséquences, FR

An accidental parachute deployment during a jump preparation led to the main canopy striking the horizontal stabilizer of a Pilatus Porter.

What happened

On May 31, 2011, a Pilatus Porter PC6-B2H4, registration F-HDEY, operated by Revolution’Air, was conducting a private skydiving session near Saint-Vaast de Longmont, France. The aircraft was carrying a pilot and five skydivers. While flying at 500 meters, the pilot maintained a speed of 70 knots to drop a wind indicator.

As the skydiver responsible for the drop opened the aircraft door, the airflow entered the cabin and caught the hand deploy device. This triggered the premature deployment of the main parachute. The force of the deployment pulled the skydaries out of the aircraft. During the inflation process, the 239 ft² main canopy struck the right side of the aircraft's horizontal stabilizer, causing the fabric to tear on the upper surface. The skydiver successfully deployed a reserve parachute and landed safely.

Although the pilot did not immediately notice a significant impact and continued the flight to complete the remaining jumps, the aircraft exhibited abnormal handling during the return to Compiègne. The pilot noted difficulty controlling the aircraft's pitch and noticed unusual behavior when using the trim controls. Upon landing, a ground inspection revealed that the adjustable horizontal stabilizer was deformed and had rotated 15 degrees to the right, causing interference with the airframe.

The investigation

The investigation focused on how the hand deploy device was activated. The skydiver involved was a highly experienced professional with over 10,000 jumps. Investigators examined the parachute and found no technical malfunctions that would cause the hand deploy to exit its storage pouch on its own. However, they noted that the device's handle protrudes slightly from the pouch.

To drop the wind indicator, the skydiver must move into a kneeling position. The investigation established that the physical act of opening the sliding door could cause the door to rub against the parachute or the door handle to snag the hand deploy handle. This movement could partially pull the device from its pouch, making it vulnerable to the high-velocity airflow entering the cabin, which then provided enough force to initiate deployment.

Probable cause

The accidental deployment was caused by the hand deploy device being partially pulled from its storage pouch due to physical contact with the aircraft door or its handle during the opening process, allowing wind ingress to trigger the main canopy.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2011-05-31 aircraft accident near Conséquences, FR?

An accidental parachute deployment during a jump preparation led to the main canopy striking the horizontal stabilizer of a Pilatus Porter.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2011-05-31 involved a aircraft, at Conséquences, FR.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The accidental deployment was caused by the hand deploy device being partially pulled from its storage pouch due to physical contact with the aircraft door or its handle during the opening process, allowing wind ingress to trigger the main canopy.

Loading the flight search…