Two fatalities in Piper C-210 stall and crash during unplanned flight training

Casualties unknown • NÃO IDENTIFICADA, PR, BR

A Piper C-210 crashed near Porecatu, Brazil, after an unplanned flight involving an untrained passenger led to a loss of control and a stall.

What happened

On February 23, 1995, a Piper C-210, registration PT-LBA, was operating in Porecatu, Paraná, for the purpose of cleaning its hopper and spray lines with water. The flight began after the pilot landed in Porecatu following a brief flight where he had distributed flowers over the city to celebrate the birth of his child. Following the landing, the pilot invited the aircraft owner to occupy the front seat for an unplanned flight intended as flight instruction.

During this second flight, the aircraft flew at low altitudes over a farm to release the water stored in the hopper. While performing a low-altitude maneuver, the aircraft entered a stall and struck the ground at a 9/0-degree angle approximately 1,000 meters from the runway threshold. The impact was followed by an explosion, resulting in two fatalities (the pilot and the passenger) and the total destruction of the aircraft.

The investigation

CENIPA's investigation focused on the operational and human factors surrounding the accident. Investigators examined the aircraft's weight and balance, noting that the center of gravity was at 25%, which was 10% above the permissible limit of 15%. The investigation also reviewed the pilot's credentials, finding that his flight instructor rating and medical certificate were both expired.

Physical examination of the wreckage was limited due to the intensity of the fire, but investigators noted the aircraft's fuel tanks contained 88 liters of remaining fuel. The investigation also looked into the psychological state of the crew, noting the lack of flight planning and the presence of an untrained passenger in a configuration intended only for a single pilot during agricultural operations.

Probable cause

The accident was caused by a loss of control during a low-altitude maneuver, driven by a combination of improper flight instruction, a center of gravity significantly aft of the allowable limits, and the presence of an untrained passenger in an unauthorized flight configuration.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 1995-02-23 aircraft accident near NÃO IDENTIFICADA, PR, BR?

A Piper C-210 crashed near Porecatu, Brazil, after an unplanned flight involving an untrained passenger led to a loss of control and a stall.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 1995-02-23 involved a aircraft, registration PTLBA, at NÃO IDENTIFICADA, PR, BR.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The accident was caused by a loss of control during a low-altitude maneuver, driven by a combination of improper flight instruction, a center of gravity significantly aft of the allowable limits, and the presence of an untrained passenger in an unauthorized flight configuration.

Loading the flight search…