Fatal Whip Stall Leads to Structural Failure of Microlight in Limpopo

Casualties unknown • Mlala Game Farm is 5.4nm north-east of Marble Hall, ZA

A scenic flight ended in tragedy when a Windlass Aquilla entered an unrecoverable whip stall, causing the wing to separate from the fuselage.

What happened

On 6 October 2018, a Windlass Aquilla microlight, registration ZU-CBR, departed the Mlala Game Farm private airstrip in Limpopo Province for a scenic flight. The flight, which included a pilot and one passenger, proceeded without incident for approximately 30 minutes.

As the aircraft approached the airstrip for landing, an eyewitness observed the aircraft at an altitude of roughly 500 feet. A sudden, unusual noise was heard, followed by the visible separation of the aircraft's wing from its main body. The fuselage underwent three longitudinal rotations before impacting the ground, while the wing settled in a nearby tree. The impact was so severe that the occupants were ejected from the aircraft after their safety harnesses failed. Both the pilot and the passenger sustained fatal injuries.

The investigation

SACAA AIID investigators examined the wreckage and analyzed data from a Garmin watch worn by the pilot. The investigation focused on the flight maneuvers performed immediately prior to the accident. Technical analysis of the aircraft's components, including bent battens, confirmed that the structural failure was a result of extreme aerodynamic forces rather than a pre-existing mechanical defect. The investigation also confirmed that the aircraft was within its mass and balance limits and that the weather conditions were clear and favorable.

Findings

  • The pilot successfully completed an initial stall maneuver without incident.
  • During a subsequent stall exercise, the pilot pushed the base bar forward, causing a steep climb that exceeded the aircraft's critical angle of attack.
  • This maneuver induced a whip stall, a high-energy aerodynamic state from which the pilot could not recover.
  • The resulting tumbling motion created a pendulum effect that caused the airframe to break apart, leading to the separation of the wing from the fuselage.
  • The failure of the safety harnesses during the sequence resulted in the occupants being thrown from the aircraft.

Probable cause

The accident was caused by the pilot exceeding the aircraft's critical angle of attack during a stall maneuver, triggering an unrecoverable whip stall and subsequent structural disintegration.

Frequently asked questions

What happened in the 2018-10-06 Windlass Aquilla accident near Mlala Game Farm is 5.4nm north-east of Marble Hall, ZA?

A scenic flight ended in tragedy when a Windlass Aquilla entered an unrecoverable whip stall, causing the wing to separate from the fuselage.

What aircraft was involved and where did it happen?

The accident on 2018-10-06 involved a Windlass Aquilla, registration ZU-CBR, at Mlala Game Farm is 5.4nm north-east of Marble Hall, ZA.

What was the probable cause of the accident?

The accident was caused by the pilot exceeding the aircraft's critical angle of attack during a stall maneuver, triggering an unrecoverable whip stall and subsequent structural disintegration.

Loading the flight search…